At this point (14) the Luciferian yields. But he wishes
to be assured that what Orthodoxus recommends has been really the
practice of the Church. This leads to a valuable chapter of Church
history. Orthodoxus recalls the victories of the Church, which the
Luciferians speak of as corrupt (15). The shame is that, though they
have the true creed, they have too little faith. He then describes (17,
18) how the orthodox bishops were beguiled into accepting the creed of
Ariminum, but afterwards saw their error (19). “The world groaned
to find itself Arian.” They did all that was possible to set
things right. Why should they not be received, as all but the authors
of heresy had been received at Nicæa? (20) Lucifer who was a good
shepherd, and Hilary the Deacon, in separating their own small body
into a sect have left the rest a prey to the wolf (20, 21). The wheat
and tares must grow together (22). This has been the principle of the
Church (23), as shown by Scripture (24) and Apostolic custom, and even
Cyprian, when he wished penitent heretics to be re-baptized (25), could
not prevail. Even Hilary by receiving baptism from the Church which
always has re-admitted heretics in repentance (26, 27) acknowledges
this principle. In that Church and its divisions and practice it is our
duty to abide.