measure, as well as a yard or a fathom. Or, to change the comparison, a small measure of capacity may be equally
accurate, to a certain degree, as a larger measure. Let the church of small attainments act charitably, and wait
for brighter evidence. If any lack wisdom, let them ask of God, who giveth liberally. “Let us therefore, as many
as be perfect, be thus minded; and if in any thing ye be otherwise minded, God shall reveal even this unto you.
Nevertheless, whereto we have already attained, let us walk by the same rule, let us mind the same thing.” 10.
The scriptural rule is not only invariable, but also perfect in its kind, as dictated by infinite wisdom for the
noblest ends. But no human character, in the present state, is perfect, so as to comport universally with the
standard. Therefore no candidate for communion is perfectly qualified; that is, his qualifications are only com-
parative. One may be qualified in a greater, and another in a smaller degree. One is qualified to fill his place
eminently, another moderately well. One may be strong, and another weak in the faith. Yet he who is weak in
the faith may be comparatively qualified. Therefore, 11. Since qualifications are so various, and admit of indef-
inite approximations to the perfect standard, or deviations from it, we are bound to accede to another conclusion,
viz. That whatever kind or degree of qualification appears to befriend, rather than to oppose, to honour, rather
than to discredit, the scriptural design of full communion, ought to be admitted by the church. When a candidate
for communion is proposed to a church, its immediate business is to consult the scriptural design of communion;
and then to consider how far the qualifications of the candidate appear to befriend and to honour it 12. From
the premises it follows, that to reason from qualifications for communion in the Jewish church, to those for full
communion in a gospel church, must needs be uncertain and inconclusive; except it could be first proved, that
the revealed design of each was the same. But it requires no great labour to show by an induction of particulars,
that the design was very different; and consequently, that what would be a suitable qualification for the one.
would not be so for the other. 13. We may further infer, that when a church requires a probable evidence of
grace as the measuring rule of admission, and directs nearly all its attention to ascertain this point, its proceedings
are irregular, unscriptural, and therefore unwarrantable. The rule of judging, as before shown, must be found
in the Scripture, and not in the candidate. 14. We may further infer from the preceding observations, that a
probable evidence of grace in a candidate, is not the precise ground of the qualification, however desirable that
evidence may be. Yet, because ordinarily, and most probably, the absence of saving grace implies the absence
of the precise ground of answerableness to the scriptural design of full communion, such probable evidence is
of great importance. However nice this distinction may appear to some, the want of attending to it seems to
have constituted the chief difference between our author and his antagonists. And, in fair investigation, another
question, different from what was agitated, ought to have been first settled, viz. Whether any person, who is not
visibly the subject of saving grace, can “befriend, rather than oppose, can honour, rather than discredit, the
scriptural design of full communion? ” Fairly to answer this question in the negative, it is not enough to prove,
that such a person cannot fully answer the scriptural design. But it ought to be proved, that no person destitute
of such probable evidence of saving grace, in any circumstances whatever, can be found, who might befriend
and honour the scriptural design of communion, rather than the contrary. This is the real hinge of the controversy.
15. It is an unscriptural notion, too much taken upon trust, that the immediate business of a church, is to form
an opinion respecting the spiritual state of a person before God; as. whether be is the subject of saving grace
—whether he has a principle of sincerity—whether his motives are spiritually pure, &c. Whereas, a church ought
not to act the part of a jury on the candidate’s real state towards God, but on his state towards the church. They
2029
SECTION XVII. Of commanding to partake.