This work against Marcion is also mentioned by Irenæus, who
quotes from it in his Adv. Hær. IV. 16. 2 (see below, chap.
18), and by Photius, Cod. 125. The work is lost, and we have
only the single brief fragment preserved by Irenæus. It is
possible that it formed a part of the larger Syntagma contra omnes
Hæreses, mentioned by Justin in his Apol. I. 26 (see
below), and it has been urged in support of this possibility that
Irenæus nowhere mentions a work of Justin’s Against all
Heresies, although it is highly probable that he made use of such a
work (see Lipsius’ Quellen der ältesten Ketzergesch.
and Harnack’s Zur Quellenkritik des Gnosticismus). It
would seem that Irenæus is referring to this work when he mentions
the Syntagma contra Marcionem. On the other hand, Photius
mentions the work against Marcion and the one against all heresies as
two separate works. He does not seem, however, to have had a personal
knowledge of them, and is possibly only repeating Eusebius (Harnack
says he is certainly doing so, Ueberlieferung d. griech. Apol.
p. 150; but in view of the fact that he omits two works mentioned by
Eusebius, this seems to be somewhat doubtful); and if this is so, no
reliance is to be placed upon his report, for it is evident that
Eusebius himself knew neither of the two works, and hence the fact that
he distinguishes them has no significance. Although, therefore, it
cannot be determined whether Justin wrote two separate works against
heretics, it is quite probable that he did not.
The conduct of Eusebius
in this connection is very peculiar. After mentioning the work against
Marcion, he at once gives a quotation in such a way as to convey the
impression that the quotation is taken from this work, but it is really
taken from the first Apology. This makes it very probable that
he had not seen this work against Marcion, a conclusion which is
confirmed by its omission from the list of Justin’s writings
given in chap. 18. It is claimed by many that Eusebius practices a
little deception here, wishing to convey the impression that he knew a
book which he did not know. This is not in accord with his usual
conduct (as he seldom hesitates to confess his ignorance of any
matter), and his general character for candor and honesty must be taken
into account in deciding the case. He does not state directly that the
quotation is taken from the work against Marcion, and it is possible
that the seeming reference of it to that source was an oversight on his
part. But it must be acknowledged, if that be the case, that he was
very careless in making the quotation.