was so universal? If God might bring this on all mankind, on occasion of other men’s sins,
for which they deserved nothing, without a revealed law, what could there be to hinder God
bringing death on men for their personal sins, for which their own consciences tell them
they deserve death without a revealed law?
2. If from Adam to Moses there had been no law in being, of any kind, revealed or nat-
ural, by which men could be properly exposed to temporal death for personal sin, yet the
mention of Moses law would have been wholly impertinent, and of no signification in the
argument, according to our author. He supposes that what the apostle would prove, is, that
temporal death comes by Adam; and not by any law threatening such a punishment for
personal sin; because this death prevailed before the law of Moses was in being, which is the
only law threatening death for personal sin. And yet he himself supposes, that the law of
Moses, when it was in being, threatened no such death for personal sin. For he abundantly
asserts, that the death which the law of Moses threatened for personal sin, was eternal death,
as has been already noted: and he says in express terms, that eternal death is of a nature
widely different from the death we now die;|| 84 as was also observed before.
How impertinently therefore does Dr. T- make an inspired writer argue, when, according
to him, the apostle would prove, that this kind of death did not come by any law threatening
this kind of death, because it came before the existence of a law threatening another kind of
death, of a nature widely different! How is it to the apostle’s purpose, to fix on that period,
the time of giving Moses’s law, as if that had been the period wherein men began to be
threatened with this punishment for their personal sins, when in truth it was no such thing?
And therefore it was no more to this purpose to fix on that period, from Adam to Moses,
than from Adam to David, or any other period whatsoever. Dr. T. holds, that even now,
since the law of Moses has been given, the mortality of mankind, or the death we now die,
does not come by that law; but that it always comes only by Adam. 85 And if it never comes
by that law, we may be sure it never was threatened in that law.
3. If we should allow the argument in Dr. T.‘s sense of it, to prove that death does not
come by personal sin, yet it will be wholly without force to prove the main point, even that
it must come by Adam’s sin: for it might come by God’s sovereign and gracious pleasure;
as innumerable other divine benefits do. If it be ordered, agreeable to our author’s supposi-
tion, not as a punishment, nor as a calamity, but only as a favour, what necessity of any
settled constitution, or revealed sentence, in order to bestow such a favour, more than other
favours; and particularly more than that great benefit, which he says entered into the world
by the sin of the antediluvians, the shortening men’s lives so much after the flood? Thus the
84 | Page 120. S. He says to the like purpose in his note on Rom. v. 17.
85 This is plain by what he says, p. 38, 40, 53, 117. S.
1094
SECTION I. Remarks on Dr. Taylor's way of explaining this text.