Chapter 5.—8. "Further," Cyprian goes on to say, "in vain do some, who are overcome
by reason, oppose to us custom, as though custom were superior to truth, or that were not
to be followed in spiritual things which has been revealed by the Holy Spirit, as the better
way."1358 This is clearly true, since reason and truth are to be preferred to custom. But
when truth supports custom, nothing should be more strongly maintained. Then he proceeds
as follows: "For one may pardon a man who merely errs, as the Apostle Paul says of himself,
‘Who was before a blasphemer, a persecutor, and injurious; but I obtained mercy, because
I did it ignorantly;’1359 but he who, after inspiration and revelation given, perseveres advisedly
and knowingly in his former error, sins without hope of pardon on the ground of ignorance.
For he rests on a kind of presumption and obstinacy, when he is overcome by reason." This
is most true, that his sin is much more grievous who has sinned wittingly than his who has
sinned through ignorance. And so in the case of the holy Cyprian, who was not only learned,
but also patient of instruction, which he so fully himself understood to be a part of the praise
of the bishop whom the apostle describes,1360 that he said, "This also should be approved
in a bishop, that he not only teach with knowledge, but also learn with patience."1361 I do
not doubt that if he had had the opportunity of discussing this question, which has been so
long and so much disputed in the Church, with the pious and learned men to whom we
owe it that subsequently that ancient custom was confirmed by the authority of a plenary
Council, he would have shown, without hesitation, not only how learned he was in those
things which he had grasped with all the security of truth, but also how ready he was to receive
instruction in what he had failed to perceive. And yet, since it is so clear that it is much
more grievous to sin wittingly than in ignorance, I should be glad if any one would tell me
which is the worse,—the man who falls into heresy, not knowing how great a sin it is, or the
man who refuses to abandon his covetousness, knowing its enormity? I might even put the
question thus: If one man unwittingly fall into heresy, and another knowingly refuse to
depart from idolatry, since the apostle himself says, "The covetous man, which is an idolater;"
and Cyprian too understood the same passage in just the same way, when he says, in his
letter to Antonianus, "Nor let the new heretics flatter themselves in this, that they say they
do not communicate with idolaters, whereas there are amongst them both adulterers and
covetous persons, who are held guilty of the sin of idolatry; ‘for know this, and understand,
that no whoremonger, nor unclean person, nor covetous man, who is an idolater, hath any
inheritance in the kingdom of Christ and of God;’1362 and again, ‘Mortify therefore your
1358 Cypr. Ep. lxxiii. 13.
1359 1 Tim. i. 13.
1360 2 Tim. ii. 24.
1361 Cypr. Ep. lxxiv. 10.
1362 Eph. v. 5.
Chapter 5
788
Chapter 5