James
the brother of John was the son of Zebedee, commonly called the
“elder” James. He was the first of the apostles to suffer
martyrdom. The other James, called “the Lord’s
brother” (Gal. i,
19.)
mentioned in v. 17 (cf. Acts xv. 13; xxi. 18)
was the Bishop of Jerusalem, a man of much importance and influence in
the apostolic church, whom Paul reckons among the “pillars”
(Gal. ii. 9). Chrys. gives no opinion here concerning him. Three views have
prevailed in the church: (1) that he was the same as the apostle, James
the son of Alphæus and is called the “brother” of
Jesus in the loose sense of that word in which it is taken as
equivalent to “relative.” (2) That he was the son of Joseph
by a former marriage. (3) That he was the son of Joseph and
Mary—the real brother of Jesus and is called an apostle in
Gal. i. 19,
in the more comprehensive sense which that word acquired according to
which it was applied also to Paul and Barnabas (Acts xiv. 14). This view seems
to me the correct one. There were also other brothers (Matt. xii. 46; Matt
xiii. 55, 56) Joses, Simon and Judas, and sisters who are not personally
named. Chrys. seems to have held view (2) in his earlier writings, but
to have adopted view (1), following Jerome. (Cf. Lightfoot on
Galatians, pp. 289, 290).—G.B.S.