prophetic. The carnal people, indeed, thought only of present blessings, though even in
connection with the people there were prophecies of the future.
These things you do not understand, because, as the prophet said, "Unless you believe,
you shall not understand."316 For you are not instructed in the kingdom of heaven,—that
is, in the true Catholic Church of Christ. If you were, you would bring forth from the
treasure of the sacred Scriptures things old as well as new. For the Lord Himself says,
"Therefore every scribe instructed in the kingdom of heaven is like an householder who
brings forth from his treasure things new and old."317 And so, while you profess to receive
only the new promises of God, you have retained the oldness of the flesh, adding only the
novelty of error; of which novelty the apostle says, "Shun profane novelties of words, for
they increase unto more ungodliness, and their speech eats like a cancer. Of whom is Hy-
menæus and Philetus, who concerning the faith have erred, saying that the resurrection is
past already, and have overthrown the faith of some." 318 Here you see the source of your
false doctrine, in teaching that the resurrection is only of souls by the preaching of the truth,
and that there will be no resurrection of the body. But how can you understand spiritual
things of the inner man, who is renewed in the knowledge of God, when in the oldness of
the flesh, if you do not possess temporal things, you concoct fanciful notions about them
in those images of carnal things of which the whole of your false doctrine consists? You
boast of despising as worthless the land of Canaan, which was an actual thing, and actually
given to the Jews; and yet you tell of a land of light cut asunder on one side, as by a narrow
wedge, by the land of the race of darkness,—a thing which does not exist, and which you
believe from the delusion of your minds; so that your life is not supported by having it, and
your mind is wasted in desiring it.319
————————————
316 Isa. vii. 9.
317 Matt. xiii. 52.
318 2 Tim. ii. 16-18.
319 [A good argumentum ad hominem, a species of argument which Augustin is fond of using.—A.H.N.]
275
Faustus’s reasons for rejecting the Old Testament, and Augustin’s animadversions…