6. Of these there has come down to us a most powerful refutation of Basilides by Agrippa
179
Castor,1025 one of the most renowned writers of that day, which shows the terrible imposture
of the man.
7. While exposing his mysteries he says that Basilides wrote twenty-four books upon
the Gospel,1026 and that he invented prophets for himself named Barcabbas and Barcoph,1027
time at which he was writing. The fact is, that Hegesippus really wrote about 175 a.d. (later therefore than Justin
Martyr), and in chap. 21 of this book Eusebius restores him to his proper chronological place. The general
statement made here by Eusebius in regard to the writers against heresy during the reign of Hadrian rest upon
his preconceived idea of what must have been the case. If the devil raised up enemies against the truth, the
Church must certainly have had at the same time defenders to meet them. It is a simple example of well-meaning
subjective reconstruction. He had the work of Agrippa Castor before him, and undoubtedly believed that he
lived at the time stated (which indeed we cannot absolutely deny), and believed, moreover, that other similar
writers, whose names he did not know, lived at the same time.
1025 Of Agrippa Castor we know only what Eusebius tells us here. Jerome (de vir. ill. chap. 21) adds nothing
new, and Theodoret’s statement (Fab. I. 4), that Agrippa wrote against Basilides’ son, Isidore, as well as against
Basilides himself, is simply an expansion of Eusebius’ account, and does not imply the existence of another work.
Agrippa’s production, of which we do not know even the title, has entirely disappeared.
1026 εἰς τὸ εὐαγγέλιον βιβλία. Clement of Alexandria (Strom. IV. 12) quotes from the twenty-third book of
the Exegetica of Basilides. Origen (Hom. in Luc. I.) says that Basilides “had even the audacity to write a Gospel
according to Basilides,” and this remark is repeated by Ambrose (Exp. in Luc. I. 1), and seems to be Jerome’s
authority for the enumeration of a Gospel of Basilides among the Apocryphal Gospels in his Comment in Matt.,
præf. We know nothing more about this Gospel, and it is quite possible that Origen mistook the Exegetica for
a Gospel. We do not know upon what Gospels Basilides wrote his Commentary (or Exegetica), but it is hardly
probable that he would have expounded his own Gospel even if such a work existed. The passage from the Ex-
egetica which Clement quotes looks to me like a part of an exposition of John ix. (although Lipsius, in the Dict.
of Christ. Biog. II. 715, suggests Luke xxi. 12). Meanwhile, in the Acta Archelai, chap. 55 (see Gallandii Bibl. PP.
III. 608), is a quotation from “the thirteenth book of the treatises (tractatuum) of Basilides,” which is an expos-
ition of the parable of Dives and Lazarus (Luke xvi.). If this is the same work, it would seem that the Exegetica
must have included at least Luke and John, possibly Matthew also, for we know that the Gospels of Matthew,
Luke, and John were all used by the Basilidians. The respective positions in the work of the expositions of the
passages from Luke and John (the former in the thirteenth, the latter in the twenty-third, book) would seem,
however, to exclude Matthew, if the books were at all of equal length. If Lipsius were correct in regarding the
latter passage as an exposition of Luke xxi. 12, there would be no evidence that the Commentary covered more
than a single Gospel.
1027 According to Epiphanius, some of the Ophites appealed to a certain prophet called Barcabbas. What
his connection was with the one mentioned here we do not know. Clement of Alexandria (Strom. VI. 6) speaks
of the Expositions of the Prophet Parchor by Isidore, the son of Basilides. This may be another of Basilides’
prophets, but is more probably identical with the oft-mentioned Barcoph. In the second book of these Expositions,
392
The Persons that became at that Time Leaders of Knowledge falsely so-ca…