Vincentius has been charged with Semipelagianism.
Whether he actually held the doctrine which was afterwards called by
that name is not clear. Certainly the express enunciation of it is
nowhere to be found in the Commonitory. But it is extremely probable
that at least his sympathies were with those who held it. For not only
does he omit the name of St. Augustine, who was especially obnoxious to
them, when making honorable mention at any time of the champions of the
faith, but he denounces his doctrine, though under a misrepresentation
of it, as one of the forms of that novel error which he
reprobates. Cardinal Noris does not
hesitate to say of him, “Non modo Semipelagianum se prodit, sed
disertis verbis Augustini discipulos tanquam hæreticos
traducit.”—Historia Pelagiana, p. 245. See
below, Appendix II. Indeed, whoever will
compare what he says in § 70 of the heresy which he describes but
forbears to name, with Prosper’s account of the charges brought
against Augustine by certain Semipelagian clergymen of
Marseilles, See Prosper’s
letter to Augustine in Augustine’s works, Ep. 225, Tom. ii. Ed.
Paris, 1836, etc. will have little
doubt that Vincentius and they had the same teacher in view, and were
of the same mind with regard to his teaching.
Be this however as it may, when it is
considered that the monks of Lérins, in common with the general
body of the churchmen of Southern Gaul, were strenuous upholders of
Semipelagianism, it will not be thought surprising that Vincentius
should have been suspected of at least a leaning in that direction.
Tillemont, who forbears to express himself decidedly, but evidently
inclines to that view, says “L’opinion qui
le condamne et l’abandonne aux Semipelagiens passe
aujourd’hui pour la plus commune parmi les
savans.” T. xv. p. 146.