See
ibid. III. 3. 4. This story is repeated by Eusebius, in Bk. IV.
chap. 14. There is nothing impossible in it. The occurrence fits well
the character of John as a “son of thunder,” and shows the
same spirit exhibited by Polycarp in his encounter with Marcion (see
below, Bk. IV. chap. 14). But the story is not very well authenticated,
as Irenæus did not himself hear it from Polycarp, but only from
others to whom Polycarp had told it. The unreliability of such
second-hand tradition is illustrated abundantly in the case of
Irenæus himself, who gives some reports, very far from true, upon
the authority of certain presbyters (e.g. that Christ lived fifty
years; II. 22. 5). This same story, with much more fullness of detail,
is repeated by Epiphanius (Hær. XXX. 24), but of Ebion (who
never existed), instead of Cerinthus. This shows that the story was a
very common one, while, at the same time, so vague in its details as to
admit of an application to any heretic who suited the purpose. That
somebody met somebody in a bath seems quite probable, and there is
nothing to prevent our accepting the story as it stands in
Irenæus, if we choose to do so. One thing, at least, is certain,
that Cerinthus is a historical character, who in all probability was,
for at least a part of his life, contemporary with John, and thus
associated with him in tradition, whether or not he ever came into
personal contact with him.