4. Let us take the points one by one, and follow the
tracks of this impiety that we may show that he has contradicted
himself. He admits that she was betrothed, and in the next breath will
have her to be a man’s wife whom he has admitted to be his
betrothed. Again, he calls her wife, and then says the only reason why
she was betrothed was that she might one day be married. And, for fear
we might not think that enough, “the word used,” he says,
“is betrothed and not intrusted, that is to say,
not yet a wife, not yet united by the bond of wedlock.” But when
he continues, “the Evangelist would never have applied the words,
before they came together to persons who were not to come
together, any more than one says, before he dined, when the man is not
going to dine,” I know not whether to grieve or laugh. Shall I
convict him of ignorance, or accuse him of rashness? Just as if,
supposing a person to say, “Before dining in harbour I sailed to
Africa,” his words could not hold good unless he were compelled
some day to dine in harbour. If I choose to say, “the apostle
Paul before he went to Spain was put in fetters at Rome,” or (as
I certainly might) “Helvidius, before he repented, was cut off by
death,” must Paul on being released at once go to Spain, or must
Helvidius repent after death, although the Scripture says Ps. vi. 5. “In sheol who shall give thee
thanks?” Must we not rather understand that the preposition before, although it
frequently denotes order in time, yet sometimes refers only to order in
thought? So that there is no necessity, if sufficient cause intervened
to prevent it, for our thoughts to be realized. When, then, the
Evangelist says before they came together, he indicates the time
immediately preceding marriage, and shows that matters were so far
advanced that she who had been betrothed was on the point of becoming a
wife. As though he said, before they kissed and embraced, before the
consummation of marriage, she was found to be with child. And she was
found to be so by none other than Joseph, who watched the swelling womb
of his betrothed with the anxious glances, and, at this time, almost
the privilege, of a husband. Yet it does not follow, as the previous
examples showed, that he had intercourse with Mary after her delivery,
when his desires had been quenched by the fact that she had already
conceived. And although we find it said to Joseph in a dream,
“Fear not to take Mary thy wife”; and again, “Joseph
arose from his sleep, and did as the angel of the Lord commanded him,
and took unto him his wife,” no one ought to be disturbed by
this, as though, inasmuch as she is called wife, she ceases to
be betrothed, for we know it is usual in Scripture to give the
title to those who are betrothed. The following evidence from
Deuteronomy establishes the point. Deut. xxii. 24, 25.
“If the man,” says the writer, “find the damsel that
is betrothed in the field, and the man force her, and lie with her, he
shall surely die, because he hath humbled his neighbour’s
wife.” And in another place, Deut. xxii. 23, 24.
“If there be a damsel that is a virgin betrothed unto an husband,
and a man find her in the city, and lie with her; then ye shall bring
them both out unto the gate of that city, and ye shall stone them with
stones that they die; the damsel, because she cried not, being in the
city; and the man, because he hath humbled his neighbour’s wife:
so thou shalt put away the evil from the midst of thee.”
Elsewhere also, Deut. xx. 7. “And
what man is there that hath betrothed a wife, and hath not taken her?
let him go and return unto his house, lest he die in the battle, and
another man take her.” But if anyone feels a doubt as to why the
Virgin conceived after she was betrothed rather than when she had no
one betrothed to her, or, to use the Scripture phrase, no husband, let
me explain that there were three reasons. First, that by the genealogy
of Joseph, whose kinswoman Mary was, Mary’s origin might also be
shown. Secondly, that she might not in accordance with the law of Moses
be stoned as an adulteress. Thirdly, that in her flight to Egypt she
might have some solace, though it was that of a guardian rather than a
husband. For who at that time would have believed the Virgin’s
word that she had conceived of the Holy Ghost, and that the angel
Gabriel had come and announced the purpose of God? and would not all
have given their opinion against her as an adulteress, like Susanna?
for at the present day, now that the whole world has embraced the
faith, the Jews argue that when Isaiah says, Is. vii. 14. See Cheyne’s Isaiah, and critical
note. “Behold, a virgin shall conceive
and bear a son,” the Hebrew word denotes a young woman, not a
virgin, that is to say, the word is Almah, not
Bethulah, a position which, farther on, we
shall dispute more in detail. Lastly, excepting Joseph, and Elizabeth,
and Mary herself, and some few others who, we may suppose, heard the
truth from them, all considered Jesus to be the son of Joseph. And so
far was this the case that even the Evangelists, expressing the
prevailing opinion, which is the correct rule for a historian, call him
the father of the Saviour, as, for instance, S. Luke ii. 27. “And he (that is, Simeon) came
in the Spirit into the temple: and when the parents brought in the
child Jesus, that they might do concerning him after the custom of the
law;” and elsewhere, S. Luke ii. 41. “And
his parents went every year to Jerusalem at the feast of the
passover.” And afterwards, ib. ii.
43.
“And when they had fulfilled the days, as they were returning,
the boy Jesus tarried behind in Jerusalem; and his parents knew not of
it.” Observe also what Mary herself, who had replied to Gabriel
with the words, ib. i.
34. “How
shall this be, seeing I know not a man?” says concerning
Joseph, S. Luke ii. 48. “Son, why hast thou thus
dealt with us? behold, thy father and I sought thee sorrowing.”
We have not here, as many maintain, the utterance of Jews or of
mockers. The Evangelists call Joseph father: Mary confesses he was
father. Not (as I said before) that Joseph was really the father of the
Saviour: but that, to preserve the reputation of Mary, he was regarded
by all as his father, although, before he heard the admonition of the
angel, S. Matt. i. 20. “Joseph, thou son of
David, fear not to take unto thee Mary thy wife: for that which is
conceived in her is of the Holy Ghost,” he had thoughts of
putting her away privily; which shows that he well knew that the child
conceived was not his. But we have said enough, more with the aim of
imparting instruction than of answering an opponent, to show why Joseph
is called the father of our Lord, and why Mary is called Joseph’s
wife. This also at once answers the
question why certain persons are called his brethren.