Excursus on the Translation of Bishops.
There are few points upon which the discipline of the Church has so completely changed
as that which regulated, or rather which forbade, the translation of a bishop from the see
for which he was consecrated to some other diocese. The grounds on which such prohibition
rested were usually that such changes were the outcome of ambition, and that if tolerated
the result would be that smaller and less important sees would be despised, and that there
would be a constant temptation to the bishops of such sees to make themselves popular
with the important persons in other dioceses with the hope of promotion. Besides this ob-
jection to translation, St. Athanasius mentions a spiritual one, that the diocese was the
bishop’s bride, and that to desert it and take another was an act of unjustifiable divorce, and
subsequent adultery.86 Canon XIV. of the Apostolic Canons does not forbid the practice
absolutely, but allows it for just cause, and although the Council of Nice is more stringent
so far as its words are concerned, apparently forbidding translation under any circumstances,
yet, as a matter of fact, that very council did allow and approve a translation.87 The general
feeling, however, of the early Church was certainly very strong against all such changes of
Episcopal cure, and there can be no doubt that the chief reason why St. Gregory Nazianzen
resigned the Presidency of the First Council of Constantinople, was because he had been
translated from his obscure see Sasima (not Nazianzum as Socrates and Jerome say) to the
Imperial City.88
From the canons of some provincial councils, and especially from those of the Third
and of the Fourth Council of Carthage, it is evident that despite the conciliar and papal
prohibitions, translations did take place, being made by the authority of the provincial
Synods, and without the consent of the pope,89 but it is also evident that this authority was
too weak, and that the aid of the secular power had often to be invoked.
This course, of having the matter decided by the synod, was exactly in accordance with
the Apostolic Canon (no. xiv.). In this manner, for example, Alexander was translated from
86 Athanas. Apol. ij.
87 Sozom. H. E. I. 2.
88 By no one has this whole matter of the translation of bishops been more carefully and thoroughly treated
than by Thomassinus, and in what follows I shall use his discussion as a thesaurus of facts. The title of his book
is Ancienne et Nouvelle Discipline de l’Église (there is also an edition in Latin). In the Third Part, and the Second
Book, Chapter LX. treats of “Translations of bishops in the Latin Church during the first five centuries.” Chapter
LXI. “Translations in the Eastern Church, during the first five centuries.” Chapter LXII. “Translation of bishops
and bishoprics between the years five hundred and eight hundred.”Chapter LXIII. “Translation under the empire
of Charlemagne and his descendants.” Chapter LXIV. “Translation of bishops after the year one thousand.” Of
all this I can in the text give but a brief resumé.
89 Thomassin. l. c. lx. viij.
Excursus on the Translation of Bishops.
94
Excursus on the Translation of Bishops.