We now perceive the subtle difference between
Marcellus and Athanasius. Neither of them could formulate the idea of
Personality in the Holy Trinity. But Athanasius, apparently on the
basis of a more thorough intelligence of Scripture (for Marcellus,
though a devout, was a partial and somewhat ignorant biblical
theologian), felt what Marcellus did not, the steady inherent personal
distinctness of the Father and the Son. Accordingly, while Athanasius
laid down and adhered to the doctrine of eternal γέννησις,
Marcellus involved himself in the mystical and confused idea of a
divine πλατυσμὸς and
συστολή.
Moreover, while Athanasius was clearsighted in his apprehension of the
problem of the day, Marcellus was after all merely conservative: he
went behind the conservatism of the Origenists,—behind even that
of the West, where Tertullian had left a sharper sense of personal
distinction in the Godhead,—to an archaic conservatism akin to
the ‘naive modalism’ of the early Church; upon this he
engrafted reflexion, in part that of the old Asiatic theology, in part
his own. As the result, his faith was such as Athanasius could not but
recognise as sincere; but in his attempt to give it theological
expression he split upon the rocks of Personality, of Eschatology, of
the divine immutability. His theology was an honest and interesting but
mistaken attempt to grapple with a problem before he understood another
which lay at its base. In doing so he exposed himself justly to attack;
but we may with Athanasius, while acknowledging this, retain a kindly
sympathy for this veteran ally of many confessors and sturdy opponent
of the alliance between science and theology.