Excursus on the Heresies Condemned in Canon I.
In treating of these heresies I shall invert the order of the canon, and shall speak of the
Macedonian and Apollinarian heresies first, as being most nearly connected with the object
for which the Constantinopolitan Synod was assembled.
The Semi-Arians, Macedonians or Pneumatomachi.
Peace indeed seemed to have been secured by the Nicene decision but there was an
element of discord still extant, and so shortly afterwards as in 359 the double-synod of
173
Rimini (Ariminum) and Selencia rejected the expressions homousionand homœusionequally,
and Jerome gave birth to his famous phrase, “the world awoke to find itself Arian.” The
cause of this was the weight attaching to the Semi-Arian party, which counted among its
numbers men of note and holiness, such as St. Cyril of Jerusalem. Of the developments of
this party it seems right that some mention should be made in this place, since it brought
forth the Macedonian heresy.
(Wm. Bright, D.D., St. Leo on the Incarnation, pp. 213 et seqq.)
The Semi-Arian party in the fourth century attempted to steer a middle course between
calling the Son Consubstantial and calling him a creature. Their position, indeed, was un-
tenable, but several persisted in clinging to it; and it was adopted by Macedonius, who occu-
pied the see of Constantinople. It was through their adoption of a more reverential language
about the Son than had been used by the old Arians, that what is called the Macedonian
heresy showed itself. Arianism had spoken both of the Son and the Holy Spirit as creatures.
The Macedonians, rising up out of Semi-Arianism, gradually reached the Church’s belief
as to the uncreated majesty of the Son, even if they retained their objection to the homoousion
as a formula. But having, in their previously Semi-Arian position, refused to extend their
own “homoiousion” to the Holy Spirit, they afterwards persisted in regarding him as “ex-
ternal to the one indivisible Godhead,” Newman’s Arians, p. 226; or as Tillemont says (Mém.
vi., 527), “the denial of the divinity of the Holy Spirit was at last their capital or only error.”
St. Athanasius, while an exile under Constantius for the second time, “heard with pain,” as
he says (Ep. i. ad Serap., 1) that “some who had left the Arians from disgust at their blasphemy
against the Son of God, yet called the Spirit a creature, and one of the ministering spirits,
differing only in degree from the Angels:” and soon afterwards, in 362, the Council of Al-
exandria condemned the notion that the Spirit was a creature, as being “no true avoidance
of the detestable Arian heresy.” See “Later Treatises of St. Athanasius,” p. 5. Athanasius
insisted that the Nicene Fathers, although silent on the nature of the Holy Spirit, had by
implication ranked him with the Father and the Son as an object of belief (ad Afros, 11).
After the death of St. Athanasius, the new heresy was rejected on behalf of the West by Pope
Damasus, who declared the Spirit to be truly and properly from the Father (as the Son from
the Divine substance) and very God, “omnia posse et omnia nosse, et ubique esse,” coequal
and adorable (Mansi, iii., 483). The Illyrian bishops also, in 374, wrote to the bishops of
Excursus on the Heresies Condemned in Canon I.
342
Excursus on the Heresies Condemned in Canon I.