Father, possesses His nature and His relation to Him that begat Him, without community645.”
Such are his words. But let us, like men who look on at their enemies engaged in a factious
struggle among themselves, consider first our adversaries’ contention against themselves,
and so proceed to set forth on the other side the true doctrine of godliness. “The Son alone,”
he says, “existing by the operation of the Father, possesses His nature and His relation to
Him that begat Him, without community.” But in his previous statements, he says that he
“does not refuse to call Him, that is begotten a ‘product of generation,’ as the generated es-
sence itself, and the appellation of Son, make such a relation of words appropriate.”
161
The contradiction existing in these passages being thus evident, I am inclined to admire
for their acuteness those who praise this doctrine. For it would be hard to say to which of
his statements they could turn without finding themselves at variance with the remainder.
His earlier statement represented that the generated essence, and the appellation of “Son,”
made such a relation of words appropriate. His present system says the contrary:—that “the
Son possesses His relation to Him that begat Him without community.” If they believe the
first statement, they will surely not accept the second: if they incline to the latter, they will
find themselves opposed to the earlier conception. Who will stay the combat? Who will
mediate in this civil war? Who will bring this discord into agreement, when the very soul
is divided against itself by the opposing statements, and drawn in different ways to contrary
doctrines? Perhaps we may see here that dark saying of prophecy which David speaks of
the Jews—“They were divided but were not pricked at heart646.” For lo, not even when they
are divided among contrariety of doctrines have they a sense of their discordancy, but they
are carried about by their ears like wine-jars, borne around at the will of him who shifts
them. It pleased him to say that the generated essence was closely connected with the appel-
lation of “Son”: straightway, like men asleep, they nodded assent to his remarks. He changed
his statement again to the contrary one, and denies the relation of the Son to Him that begat
Him: again his well-beloved friends join in assent to this also, shifting in whatever direction
he chooses, as the shadows of bodies change their form by spontaneous mimicry with the
motion of the advancing figure, and even if he contradicts himself, accepting that also. This
is another form of the drought that Homer tells us of, not changing the bodies of those who
drink its poison into the forms of brutes, but acting on their souls to produce in them a
change to a state void of reason. For of those men, the tale tells that their mind was sound,
while their form was changed to that of beasts, but here, while their bodies remain in their
645 This seems to be the force of ἀκοινώνητον: it is clear from what follows that it is to be understood as
denying community of essence between the Father and the Son, not as asserting only the unique character alike
of the Son and of His relation to the Father.
646 This is the LXX. version of the last part of Ps. xxxv. 15, a rendering with which the Vulgate version prac-
tically agrees.
308
He proceeds again to discuss the impassibility of the Lord's generation;…