Let us proceed, however, to what
follows in order. He says that the generation of the essence is
“without intervention,” and that it “preserves
indivisible its relation to its Generator, Maker, and Creator.”
Well, if he had spoken of the immediate and indivisible character of
the essence, and stopped his discourse there, it would not have swerved
from the orthodox view, since we too confess the close connection and relation
of the Son with the Father, so that there is nothing inserted between
them which is found to intervene in the connection of the Son with the
Father, no conception of interval, not even that minute and indivisible
one, which, when time is divided into past, present, and future, is
conceived indivisibly by itself as the present, as it cannot be
considered as a part either of the past or of the future, by reason of
its being quite without dimensions and incapable of division, and
unobservable, to whichever side it might be added. That, then, which is
perfectly immediate, admits we say, of no such intervention; for that
which is separated by any interval would cease to be immediate. If,
therefore, our author, likewise, in saying that the generation of the
Son is “without intervention,” excluded all these ideas,
then he laid down the orthodox doctrine of the conjunction of Him Who
is with the Father. When, however, as though in a fit of repentance, he
straightway proceeded to add to what he had said that the essence
“preserves its relation to its Generator, Maker, and
Creator,” he polluted his first statement by his second, vomiting
forth his blasphemous utterance upon the pure doctrine. For it is clear
that there too his “without intervention” has no orthodox
intention, but, as one might say that the hammer is mediate between the
smith and the nail, but its own making is “without
intervention,” because, when tools had not yet been found out by
the craft, the hammer came first from the craftsman’s hands by
some inventive process, not It
seems necessary for the sense to read οὐ δι᾽
ἑτέρου τινὸς
ὀργάνου,
since the force of the comparison consists in the hammer being produced
immediately by the smith: otherwise we must understand δι᾽
ἑτέρου τινὸς
ὀργάνου to
refer to the employment of some tool not properly belonging to
the τέχνη of the
smith: but even so the parallel would be destroyed. by means of any other
tool, and so by it the others were made; so the phrase, “without
intervention,” indicates that this is also our author’s
conception touching the Only-begotten. And here Eunomius is not alone
in his error as regards the enormity of his doctrine, but you may find
a parallel also in the works of Theognostus Theognostus, a writer of the third century, is said to have been
the head of the Catechetical School at Alexandria, and is quoted by S.
Athanasius as an authority against the Arians. An account of his work
is to be found in Photius, and this is extracted and printed with the
few remaining fragments of his actual writings in the 3rd volume of
Routh’s Reliquiæ Sacræ., who
says that God, wishing to make this universe, first brought the Son
into existence as a sort of standard of the creation; not perceiving
that in his statement there is involved this absurdity, that what
exists, not for its own sake, but for the sake of something else, is
surely of less value than that for the sake of which it exists: as we
provide an implement of husbandry for the sake of life, yet the plough
is surely not reckoned as equally valuable with life. So, if the Lord
also exists on account of the world, and not all things on account of
Him, the whole of the things for the sake of which they say He exists,
would be more valuable than the Lord. And this is what they are here
establishing by their argument, where they insist that the Son has His
relation to His Creator and Maker “without
intervention.”