By what reasoning then is it,
and by what arguments, according to that invincible logic of his, that
he wins back the opinion of the mass of men, and follows out at his
pleasure this line of thought, that as the God Who is over all is
conceived and spoken of both as “Creator” and as
“Father,” the Son has a close connection with both titles,
being equally called both “product of creation” and
“product of generation”? For as customary accuracy of
speech distinguishes between names of this kind, and applies the name
of “generation” in the case of things generated from the
essence itself, and understands that of “creation” of those
things which are external to the nature of their maker, and as on this
account the Divine doctrines, in handing down the knowledge of God,
have delivered to us the names of “Father” and
“Son,” not those of “Creator” and
“work,” that there might arise no error tending to
blasphemy (as might happen if an appellation of the latter kind
repelled the Son to the position of an alien and a stranger), and that
the impious doctrines which sever the Only-begotten from essential
affinity with the Father might find no entrance—seeing all this,
I say, he who declares that the appellation of “product of
making” is one befitting the Son, will safely say by consequence
that the name of “Son” is properly applicable to that which
is the product of making; so that, if the Son is a “product of
making,” the heaven is called “Son,” and the
individual things that have been made are, according to our author,
properly named by the appellation of “Son.” For if He has
this name, not because He shares in nature with Him that begat Him, but
is called Son for this reason, that He is created, the same argument
will permit that a lamb, a dog, a frog, and all things that exist by
the will of their maker, should be named by the title of
“Son.” If, on the other hand, each of these is not a Son
and is not called God, by reason of its being external to the nature of
the Son, it follows, surely, that He Who is truly Son is Son, and is
confessed to be God by reason of His being of the very nature of Him
that begat Him. But Eunomius abhors the idea of generation, and
excludes it from the Divine doctrine, slandering the term by his
fleshly speculations. Well, our discourse, in what precedes, showed
sufficiently on this point that, as the Psalmist says, “they are
afraid where no fear is Cf. Ps. liii. 6.” For if it was
shown in the case of men that not all generation exists by way of
passion, but that that which is material is by passion, while that
which is spiritual is pure and incorruptible, (for that which is
begotten of the Spirit is spirit and not flesh, and in spirit we see no
condition that is subject to passion,) since our author thought it
necessary to estimate the Divine power by means of examples among
ourselves, let him persuade himself to conceive from the other mode of
generation the passionless character of the Divine generation.
Moreover, by mixing up together these three names, of which two are
equivalent, he thinks that his readers, by reason of the community of
sense in the two phrases, will jump to the conclusion that the third is
equivalent also. For since the appellation of “product of
making,” and “product of creation,” indicate that the
thing made is external to the nature of the maker, he couples with
these the phrase, “product of generation,” that this too
may be interpreted along with those above mentioned. But argument of
this sort is termed fraud and falsehood and imposition, not a
thoughtful and skilful demonstration. For that only is called
demonstration which shows what is unknown from what is acknowledged;
but to reason fraudulently and fallaciously, to conceal your own
reproach, and to confound by superficial deceits the understanding of
men, as the Apostle says, “of corrupt minds 2 Tim. iii. 8.,” this no sane man would call a skilful
demonstration.