The commission returned to Tyre, where the
council passed a resolution (Soz. ii. 25) deposing Athanasius. They
then proceeded to Jerusalem for the Dedication The Greek
Church still commemorates this Festival on Sep. 13; the Chron.
Pasch. gives Sep. 17 for the Dedication. But if the Mareotic
Commissioners returned to Tyre, as they certainly did (Soz. l.c.),
these dates are untrustworthy. of the
Church of the Holy Sepulchre. Here Arius with certain others (probably
including Euzoius) was received to communion on the strength of the
confession of faith he had presented to Constantine a few years before,
and the assembled bishops drew up a synodal letter announcing the fact
to Egypt and the Church at large (pp. 144, 460). At this juncture the
summons from Constantine arrived. The terms of it shewed that the
Emperor was not disposed to hear more of the broken chalice or the
murdered Arsenius: but the Eusebians were not at a loss. They advised
the bishops to go quietly to their homes, while five of the inner
circle, accompanied by Eusebius of Cæsarea, who had a panegyric to
deliver in the imperial presence, responded to the summons of royalty.
They made short work of Athanasius. The whole farrago of charges
examined at Tyre was thrown aside. He had threatened to starve the
πανευδαίμων
πατρίς, the chosen capital of
Constantine, by stopping the grain ships which regularly left
Alexandria every autumn. It was in vain for Athanasius to protest that
he had neither the means nor the power to do anything of the kind.
‘You are a rich man,’ replied Eusebius of Nicomedia,
‘and can do whatever you like.’ The Emperor was touched in
a sore place The
philosopher Sopater had been put to death on a similar charge a few
years before, D.C.B. i. 631.. He promptly ordered the banishment of
Athanasius to Treveri, whither he started, as it would seem, on Feb. 5,
336 (pp. 105, 146, 503, note 11). The friends of Athanasius professed
to regard the banishment as an act of imperial clemency, in view of
what might have been treated as a capital matter, involving as it did
the charge of treason (p. 105); and Constantine II., immediately after
his father’s death, stated (pp. 146, 272, 288) in a letter
(written before he became Augustus in Sept. 337) that he had been sent
to Treveri merely to keep him out of danger, and that Constantine had
been prevented only by death from carrying out his intention of
restoring him. These charitable constructions need not be rudely
ignored; but in all probability the anxiety to be rid of a cause of
disturbance was at least one motive with the peace-loving Emperor. At
any rate the Eusebians could not
obtain the imperial sanction to their proposed election of a successor
(Pistus?) to Athanasius. On his return after the death of Constantine
he found his see waiting for him unoccupied (Apol. c. Ar. 29, p.
115).