Chapter 1.—That the Nature of the Angels, Both Good and Bad, is One and the Same.
It has already, in the preceding book, been shown how the two cities originated among
the angels. Before I speak of the creation of man, and show how the cities took their rise so
far as regards the race of rational mortals I see that I must first, so far as I can, adduce what
may demonstrate that it is not incongruous and unsuitable to speak of a society composed
of angels and men together; so that there are not four cities or societies,—two, namely, of
angels, and as many of men,—but rather two in all, one composed of the good, the other of
the wicked, angels or men indifferently.
That the contrary propensities in good and bad angels have arisen, not from a difference
in their nature and origin, since God, the good Author and Creator of all essences, created
them both, but from a difference in their wills and desires, it is impossible to doubt. While
some steadfastly continued in that which was the common good of all, namely, in God
Himself, and in His eternity, truth, and love; others, being enamored rather of their own
power, as if they could be their own good, lapsed to this private good of their own, from
that higher and beatific good which was common to all, and, bartering the lofty dignity of
eternity for the inflation of pride, the most assured verity for the slyness of vanity, uniting
love for factious partisanship, they became proud, deceived, envious. The cause, therefore,
of the blessedness of the good is adherence to God. And so the cause of the others’ misery
will be found in the contrary, that is, in their not adhering to God. Wherefore, if when the
question is asked, why are the former blessed, it is rightly answered, because they adhere to
God; and when it is asked, why are the latter miserable, it is rightly answered, because they
do not adhere to God,—then there is no other good for the rational or intellectual creature
save God only. Thus, though it is not every creature that can be blessed (for beasts, trees,
stones, and things of that kind have not this capacity), yet that creature which has the capacity
cannot be blessed of itself, since it is created out of nothing, but only by Him by whom it
has been created. For it is blessed by the possession of that whose loss makes it miserable.
He, then, who is blessed not in another, but in himself, cannot be miserable, because he
cannot lose himself.
Accordingly we say that there is no unchangeable good but the one, true, blessed God;
that the things which He made are indeed good because from Him, yet mutable because
made not out of Him, but out of nothing. Although, therefore, they are not the supreme
good, for God is a greater good, yet those mutable things which can adhere to the immutable
good, and so be blessed, are very good; for so completely is He their good, that without Him
they cannot but be wretched. And the other created things in the universe are not better
on this account, that they cannot be miserable. For no one would say that the other members
That the Nature of the Angels, Both Good and Bad, is One and the Same.
516
That the Nature of the Angels, Both Good and Bad, is One and the Same.