THE DIALOGUE AGAINST THE LUCIFERIANS.
325
be said that we must believe that the eunuch
whom Philip ' baptized lacked the Holy Spirit. The Scripture thus speaks concerning him,
" And they both went down into the water ;
and Philip baptized him." And on leaving the water, " The Holy Spirit fell upon the
eunuch." You may perhaps think that we ought to set against this the passage in which
we read, " Now when the apostles which were at Jerusalem heard that Samaria had received
the word of God, they sent unto them Peter
and John : who, when they were come down,
prayed for them that they might receive the
Holy Ghost : for as yet he was fallen upon
none of them." But why this was, the context
tells us, — " Only they had been baptized into the name of the Lord Jesus. Then laid they
their hands on them, and they received the
Holy Ghost." And if you here say that you do the same, because the heretics have not
baptized into the Holy Spirit, I must remind
you that Philip was not separated from the
Apostles, but belonged to the same Church
and preached the same Lord Jesus Christ :
that he was without question a deacon of
those who afterwards laid their hands on his
converts. But when you say that the Arians
have not a Church, but a synagogue, and that
their clergy do not worship God but creatures
and idols, how can you maintain that you
ought to act upon the same principle in cases
so totally different ?
L. You repel my attack in front with vigour
and firmness : but you are smitten in the
rear and leave your back exposed to the darts.
Let us even grant that the Arians have no
baptism, and therefore that the Holy Ghost can-
not be given by them, because they themselves
have not yet received remission of sins ; this
altogether makes for victory on my side, and
all your argumentative wrestling is but labori-
ous toil to give me the conqueror's palm. An Arian has no baptism ; how is it then that he
has the episcopate ? There is not even a lay-
man among them, how can there be a bishop ? I
may not receive a beggar, do you receive a
king ? You surrender your camp to the enemy,
and are we to reject one of their deserters ?
ii. O. If you remember what has been said
you would know that you have been already
answered ; but in yielding to the love of con- tradiction you have wandered from the subject,
like those persons who are talkative rather
than eloquent, and who, when they cannot
argue, still continue to wrangle. On the pres-
ent occasion it is not my aim to either accuse
or defend the Arians, but rather to get safely
past the turning-post of the race, and to main-
tain that we receive a bishop for the same
reason that you receive a layman. If you
grant forgiveness to the erring, I too pardon
the penitent. If he that baptizes a person into
our belief has had no injurious effect upon the
person baptized, it follows that he who con- secrates a bishop in the same faith causes no
defilement to the person consecrated. Heresy
is subtle, and therefore the simple-minded are
easily deceived. To be deceived is the com- mon lot of both layman and bishop. But you
say, a bishop could not have been mistaken.
The truth is, men are elected to the episcopate
who come from the bosom of Plato and Aris-
tophanes. How many can you find among
them who are not fully instructed in these
writers ? Indeed all, whoever they may be, that
are ordained at the present day from among the
i literate class make it their study not how to seek
out the marrow of Scripture, but how to tickle
the ears of the people with the flowers of rhetoric. We must further add that the Arian
| heresy goes hand in hand with the wisdom of
; the world, and ' borrows its streams of argu- ment from the fountains of Aristotle. And so
we will act like children when they try to outdo
one another — whatever you say I will say : what
you assert, I will assert : whatever you deny,
I will deny. We allow that an Arian may
baptize ; then he must be a bishop.8 If we agree that Arian baptism is invalid, you must
reject the layman, and I must not accept the
bishop. I will follow you wherever you go ;
we shall either stick in the mud together, or
shall get out together.
12. L. We pardon a layman because, when
he was baptized, he had a sincere impression
that he was joining the Church. He believed
and was baptized in accordance with his faith.
O. That is something new for a man to be
made a Christian by one who is not a Chris-
tian. When he joined the Arians into what
faith was he baptized ? Of course into that
which the Arians held. If on the other hand
we are to suppose that his own faith was cor-
rect, but that he was knowingly baptized by
heretics, he does not deserve the indulgence
we grant to the erring. But it is quite absurd
to imagine that, going as a pupil to the master, he understands his art before he has been
taught. Can you suppose that a man who has
just turned from worshipping idols knows
Christ better than his teacher does? If you
1 Acts viii. »6 sq.
1 "The philosophical relations of Arianistn have been differ- ently stated. Baur, Newman (The Arians, p. 17), and others,
bring it into connection with Aristotle, and Athanasianism with
Plato ; Petavius, Ritter, and Voigt, on the contrary, derive the
Arian idea of God from Platonism and Neo-Platonism. The
empirical, rational, logical tendency of Arianism is certainly more Aristotelian than Platonic, and so far Baur and Newman
are right; but all depends on making either revelation and faith,
or philosophy and reason, the starting point and ruling power of
theology." Doctor Schaff in Diet, of Chris. Biog. 2 Baptism was at this time, as a rule, administered by the bishop alone.