The controversy of the two Dionysii has another
interesting side, as bearing upon the means then employed for dealing
with questions affecting the Church as a whole,—and in particular
upon the position of the Roman Church as the natural referee in such
questions. (Cf. Prolegg. ch. iv. §4.) This is not the place for a
general discussion of the question, or for an attempt to trace its
history previous to the case before us. But it should be noted,
firstly, that when the Pentapolite (?) opponents of Dionysius desire a
lever against him, their first resource is not a council of local
bishops, but the Roman Church: secondly, that the Roman bishop takes up
the case, and writes to his Alexandrian namesake for an explanation:
thirdly, that the explanation asked for is promptly given.
Unfortunately the fragment of the Roman letter preserved to us by
Athanasius tells us nothing of the form of the intervention, whether it
was the request of one co-trustee to another for an explanation of the
latter’s action in a matter concerning their common trust, or
whether it was coupled with any assumption of jurisdiction at all like
that involved in the letter of the Bishop of Alexandria to those of
Libya. At any rate, the latter alternative has no positive evidence in
our documents; and the fragments of the Refutation and Defence
‘shew the most complete and resolute independence. There is
nothing in the narrative of Athanasius which implies that the
Alexandrine Bishop recognised or that the Roman Bishop claimed any
dogmatic authority as belonging to the Imperial See.’ The letter
of Dionysius of Rome is certainly highly characteristic of the
indifference to theological reasoning and the close adherence to the
rule of faith as the authoritative solution of all questions of
doctrine which marks the genius of Rome as contrasted with that of
Alexandria (see Gore, The Church and the Ministry, ch. i. sub
fin., and Harnack, Dg. i. 686, who observes upon the
striking family likeness between this letter and that of Leo to
Flavian, and of Agatho to the Sixth Ecumenical Council). Lastly, the
Roman Church, which never troubled about a precedent adverse to her
imperial instinct, never forgot one which favoured it. The intervention
of Dionysius was treasured up in her memory, and, when the time came,
fully exploited (supr. p. 113, note 3, where the note
distinguishes somewhat too carefully between the ‘Pope’ of
Rome and the ‘Bishop,’ πάπας, of Alexandria).