“This
Apology,” says Montfaucon, “is the most authentic source of
the history of the Church in the first half of the fourth century.
Athanasius is far superior to any other historians of the period, both
from his bearing for the most part a personal testimony to the facts he
relates, and from his great accuracy and use of actual documents. On
the other hand, Rufinus, Socrates, Sozomen, Theodoret, must not be used
without extreme caution, unless they adduce documents, which is seldom
the case.” The ‘Apology’ is a personal defence by
Athanasius against the charges laid against him by the Eusebian party,
and does not directly concern matters of doctrine. After the Council of
Nicæa, the Eusebian policy had been to oust the principal
opponents from their sees on personal grounds, so as to pave the way
for the abrogation of the Nicene formula. The attack upon Athanasius
began in 331, but without success. It was renewed at Cæsarea and
Tyre in 334–335, and resulted in the exile of Athanasius to
Treveri, 336. His return in 337 was followed by a Synod at Antioch
which ‘deposed’ him (close of 338), and by his expulsion in
favour of Gregory (339). Then follow the intervention of Julius
(339–340), and the Council of Sardica (343), which resulted in
the eventual return of Athanasius in the autumn of 346. (The details
are given more fully in the Prolegomena, ch. ii.
§§4–6). After this latter date, and before the relapse
of Valens and Ursacius which followed upon the death of Constans,
Athanasius drew up a collection of documents in proof of his innocence,
connecting them together by an explanatory narrative. (1) The
charges against him related to events alleged to have occurred
before the year 332 (extortion of money, subvention of the rebel
Philumenus, the chalice of Ischyras, murder and mutilation of the
bishop Arsenius): the principal evidence as to their falsehood was
comprised in the proceedings of the Councils of Tyre and Jerusalem, and
of the commission of enquiry sent by the assembled bishops to the
Mareotis. (2) The judicial investigations which proved the
innocence of Athanasius took place first at Rome under Julius, secondly
at Sardica under Hosius; and were followed by the recognition of his
innocence on the part of the Emperor Constantius, of bishops in various
parts of the world, and lastly of some of his chief accusers.