It may therefore be worth while to devote a word
or two to some peculiarities incidental to its aim and method. We
observe first of all how completely the power of the writer is absorbed
in the subject under discussion. It is therefore highly precarious to
infer anything from his silence even on points which might seem to
require explanation in the course of his argument. Not a word is said
of the doctrine of the Trinity, nor of the Holy Spirit; this directly
follows from the purpose of the work, in accordance with the general
truth that while the Church preaches Christ to the World, the Office
and Personality of the Spirit belongs to her inner life. The teaching
of the tract with regard to the constitution of man is another case in
point. It might appear (§3, cf. 11. 2, 13. 2) that Athanasius
ascribed the reasonable soul of man, and his immortality after death,
not to the constitution of human nature as such, but to the grace
superadded to it by the Creator (ἡ τοῦ κατ᾽
εἰκόνα
χάρις), a grace which constituted men λογικοί (3. 4) by
virtue of the power of the Logos, and which, if not forfeited by
sin, involved the privilege of immortality. We have, then, to
carefully consider whether Athanasius held, or meant to suggest, that
man is by nature, and apart from union with God, (1) rational, or (2)
immortal. If we confine our view to the treatise before us, there would
be some show of reason in answering both questions in the negative; and
with regard to immortality this has been recently done by an able
correspondent of The Times (April 9, 1890).