to it, in any nation or age? Are there any such kind of laws or regulations to be found in any
nation, city, or family; in any society, civil, military or academic, stated or occasional, that
the society should be required to insist on some credible pretence and evidence of a certain
qualification, in order to persons being admitted to the privileges of the society; prohibiting
their being admitted under any other notion than as persons possessed of that qualification,
or without a respect in their admission to such a character appearing on them: and yet at the
same time, by the laws of that very society, that qualification is not necessary; but persons
are declared, without any such qualification, to have a lawful right, to be fit matter, to be
duly qualified, and to have sufficient qualifications to be admitted to these privileges, without
that qualification?
496
If some men have a right in the sight of God to sacraments without true piety, and are
fit and duly qualified without it, in his sight and by his institution, and yet the church must
not admit them unless they are truly pious in their sight; then the eye of man must require
higher terms, than the infinitely holy eye of God himself; they must look for something that
the eye of God looks not for, and which he judges them duly qualified without.
Mr. W. when speaking of the evidence, on which he supposes the church ought to judge
persons to be real saints, from time to time adds, that on such evidence “The church is ob-
liged, in their external carriage, to treat them as saints, and admit them to the external
privileges of the church.”—So, p. 9. d. p. 12. a. &c. p. 13. a. b. and p. 14. c. and in other places.
But what does he mean by treating them as saints, in admitting them to the external privileges
of the church? If sinners have as much of a lawful right to these privileges, as saints, then
why is giving them these privileges, a treating them as saints, any more than as sinners? If
it belongs to an ignorant child, to be admitted into school, as much as one that is learned,
then how is it treating him as one that is learned, to admit him? Mr. W. (p. 11. d. e.) giving
a reason why he that professes conviction of the truth of the gospel, &c. ought to be admitted
to sacraments, says, “Though this conviction may be only by moral evidence and common
illumination, yet—the church knows not but it is done on a divine and gracious discovery.”
But how can this be a reason? What if the church did know that it was not on a gracious
discovery, if the man has a right in the sight of God without, and God has made it his duty
to come to sacraments without it? Surely the church have no right to forbid him to do that
which God has given him a right to do, and made it his duty to do; as Mr. S. says, (Doct. of
Inst. Churches, p. 20. b.) The church may not hinder any man from doing his duty.
Therefore if this be Mr. S—d’s question, Whether some unsanctified men may lawfully
come to the Lord’s supper, and if this be the grand point in dispute, the thing which Mr.
W. undertakes to maintain, as he often declares, then it is most plainly evident, that in
conceding and asserting those things forementioned, he does in effect abundantly give up
that which he himself insists on as the grand point in controversy; and so makes void and
vain all his own labour, and for himself effectually confutes all that he has written.
1927
SECTION III. Of ungodly men's communing.