56. Scripture, in speaking thus, implies, O
Arians, not that the Son is originate, but rather other than things
originate, and proper to the Father, being in His bosom. (4.) Nor There
is apparently much confusion in the arrangement of the paragraphs that
follow; though the appearance may perhaps arise from Athan.’s
incorporating some passage from a former work into his text, cf. note
on §32. It is easy to suggest alterations, but not anything
satisfactory. The same ideas are scattered about. Thus συγκριτικῶς
occurs in (3) and (5). The Son’s seat on the
right, and Angels in ministry, (3) fin. (10) (11). ‘Become’
interpreted as ‘is originated and is,’ (4) and (11). The
explanation of ‘become,’ (4) (9) (11) (14). The
Word’s ἐπιδημία
is introduced in (7) and (8) παρουσία
being the more common word; ἐπιδημία occurs Orat. ii. §67 init. Serap. i. 9. Vid.
however, §61, notes. If a change must be suggested, it would be to
transfer (4) after (8) and (10) after (3). does even the expression
‘become,’ which here occurs, shew that the Son is
originate, as ye suppose. If indeed it were simply ‘become’
and no more, a case might stand for the Arians; but, whereas they are
forestalled with the word ‘Son’ throughout the passage,
shewing that He is other than things originate, so again not even the
word ‘become’ occurs absolutely ἀπολελυμένως. vid. also Orat. ii. 54. 62. iii. 22. Basil.
contr. Eunom. i. p. 244. Cyril. Thesaur. 25, p.
236. διαλελυμένως. Orat. iv. 1.,
but ‘better’ is immediately subjoined. For the writer
thought the expression immaterial, knowing that in the case of one who
was confessedly a genuine Son, to say ‘become’ is the same
with saying that He had been made, and is, ‘better.’ For it
matters not even if we speak of what is generate, as
‘become’ or ‘made;’ but on the contrary, things
originate cannot be called generate, God’s handiwork as they are,
except so far as after their making they partake of the generate Son,
and are therefore said to have been generated also, not at all in their
own nature, but because of their participation of the Son in the
Spirit [The
note, referred to above, p. 169, in which Newman defends the treatment
of γενητὸν and γεννητὸν as synonymous, while yet admitting that they are expressly
distinguished by Ath. in the text, is omitted for lack of
space.]. And this again divine Scripture
recognises; for it says in the case of things originate, ‘All
things came to be through Him, and without Him nothing came to be John i. 3.,’ and, ‘In wisdom hast Thou made
them all Ps. civ. 24.;’ but in the case of sons which
are generate, ‘To Job there came to be seven sons and three
daughters Job i. 2.,’ and, ‘Abraham was an
hundred years old when there came to be to him Isaac his son Gen. xxi. 5.;’ and Moses said Cf. Deut. xxi. 15., ‘If to any one there come to be
sons.’ Therefore since the Son is other than things originate,
alone the proper offspring of the Father’s essence, this plea of
the Arians about the word ‘become’ is worth nothing.