This and the next epistle were occasioned by the Donatist schism.
This great schism arose after the close of the Diocletian persecution,
and divided the church of North Africa for more than a century. Like
the Novatian schism, it was due to the conflict of the more rigid and
the more indulgent theories of discipline. In Novatianism, however, the
burning question was the readmission of the lapsed; in Donatism, the
validity of clerical functions performed by unholy or unfaithful
clergymen. In the latter, therefore, the question was one of clerical,
not lay discipline, and there was involved in it a very important
theological principle. The Donatists maintained that the validity of
clerical functions depended upon the character of the administering
clergyman; the Catholic party maintained that the validity of those
functions depended solely upon Christ, and was quite independent of the
character of the officiating clergyman, provided he had been duly
qualified by the Church for the performance of such functions.
Augustine, nearly a century after the rise of the sect, found it
necessary to oppose it, and it was in the controversy with it that he
developed his doctrine of the Church and the Sacraments. The immediate
occasion of the schism was the election of Cæcilianus, who favored
the milder principles of church discipline, to the bishopric of
Carthage, in 311. His election was opposed by the entire rigoristic
party in Carthage and throughout North Africa. It was claimed that the
Bishop Felix of Aptunga, by whom he was ordained, had been a traditor
during the persecution, and that therefore Cæcilian’s
ordination was not valid. As a consequence the bishops of Numidia, who
had not been invited to assist in the choice and ordination of
Cæcilian, held a synod in Carthage, and elected a counter-bishop,
Majorinus. Thus the schism was definitely launched. The party called
itself for a time by the name of its first bishop, but in 315 he was
succeeded by Donatus, called the Great, to distinguish him from
Donatus, bishop of Casæ Nigræ, who had been one of the
original leaders of the movement. From him the sect took the name by
which it was thenceforth known. Doubtless personal jealousies and
enmities had considerable to do with the origin of the schism, but it
is quite inaccurate to ascribe it wholly to such causes. The
fundamental ground lay in the deep-seated difference in principles
between the two parties in the Church, and it was inevitable that that
difference should make itself felt in some such rupture, even had
personal reasons not co-operated to such an extent as they did. Our
chief sources for a knowledge of Donatism are the anti-Donatistic works
of Augustine (see The Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, first
series, Vol. IV. p. 369 sq.), together with a number of his epistles,
and Optatus’ De Schismate Donatistarum. The literature on
the subject is very extensive. See especially Valesius’ essay,
De Schismate Donat., appended to his edition of Eusebius
(Reading’s edition, p. 775 sq.); Ribbeck, Donatus and
Augustinus, 1858; the articles Cæcilianus and
Donatism in the Dict. of Christ. Biog.; Neander’s
Church History, Torrey’s translation, II. p. 182 sq.;
Hefele’s Conciliengesch. 2d ed., I. p. 293 sq.; and
Schaff’s Church History, III. p. 360 sq. Constantine did
not voluntarily meddle in the Donatistic controversy. He was first
appealed to by the Donatists themselves, through the proconsul
Anulinus, early in the year 313 (see Augustine, Epistle 88, for
a copy of the letter in which Anulinus communicates their request to
the emperor). In response to their appeal Constantine (in the present
epistle) summoned the two parties to appear before a Roman synod, which
was held in October, 313. The Donatists were unable to prove their
charges, and the synod gave decision against them. Again, at their own
request, their case was heard at a council held in Gaul the following
year (the synod of Arles; see the next epistle of Constantine quoted in
this chapter). This council also decided against them, and the
Donatists appealed once more to the judgment of the emperor himself. He
heard their case in Milan in 316, and confirmed the decisions of the
councils, and soon afterward issued laws against them, threatening them
with the banishment of their bishops and the confiscation of their
property. He soon, however, withdrew his persecuting measures, and
adopted a policy of toleration. During subsequent reigns their
condition grew worse, and they were often obliged to undergo severe
hardships; but they clung rigidly to their principles until the
invasion of the Vandals in 428, when the entire North African Church
was devastated.