or church in their admissions ever proceeded on the supposition, that all whom they took
into communion were so versed in this controversy, as this comes to? Has it ever been the
manner to examine them as to their thorough acquaintance with this particular controversy?
Has it been the manner to put by those who had only an opinion and not a certainty; even
as the priests who could not find their register, were put by, till the matter could be determined
by Urim and Thummim? And I dare appeal to every minister, and every member of a church
that has been concerned in admitting communicants, whether they ever imagined, or it ever
entered into their thought, concerning each one to whose admission they have consented,
that they had looked so much into this matter, as not only to have settled their opinion, but
to be arrived to a proper certainty?
(2.) I desire it may be remembered, that the venerable author of the Appeal to the Learned,
did in his ministry ever teach such doctrine from whence it will unavoidably follow, that
no one unconverted man in the world can know he has a warrant to come to the Lord’s
supper. For if any unconverted man has a warrant to worship his Maker in this way, it must
be because God has given him such warrant by the revelation of his mind in the Holy
Scriptures. And therefore if any unconverted man not only thinks, but knows, he has a
warrant from God, he must of consequence, not only think, but know, that the Scriptures
are the word of God. But I believe all that survive of the stated hearers of that eminent divine,
and all who were acquainted with him, well remember it to be a doctrine which he often
470
taught and much insisted on, that no natural man knows the Scripture to be the word of
God; that although such may think so, yet they do not know it; and that at best they have
but a doubtful opinion: and he often would express himself thus; No natural man is thoroughly
convinced, that the Scriptures are the word of God; if they were convinced, they would be
gained. Now if so, it is impossible any natural man in the world should ever know, it is his
right, in his present condition, to come to the Lord’s supper. True, he may think it is his
right, he may have that opinion: but he cannot know it; and so must not come, according
to this argument. For it is only the word of God in the Holy Scriptures, that gives a man a
right to worship the Supreme Being in this sacramental manner, and to come to him in this
way, or any other, as one in covenant with him. The Lord’s supper being no branch of nat-
ural worship, reason without institution is no ground of duty or right in this affair. And
hence it is plainly impossible for those that do not so much as know the Scriptures are the
word of God, to know they have any good ground of duty or right in this matter. Therefore,
supposing unconverted men have a real right, yet since they have no known right, they have
no warrant (according to the argument before us) to take and use their right; and what good
then can their right do them? Or how can they excuse themselves from presumption, in
claiming a right, which they do not know belongs to them?—It is said, a probable hope that
persons are regenerate, will not warrant them to come; if they come, they take a liberty to
do that which they do not know God gives them leave to do, which is horrible presumption
1850
OBJ. IX. If grace be required, it must be known.