Chapter XXIX.—Nicolaus and the Sect named after him.
1. At this time the so-called sect of the Nicolaitans made its appearance and lasted for
a very short time. Mention is made of it in the Apocalypse of John.842 They boasted that
the author of their sect was Nicolaus, one of the deacons who, with Stephen, were appointed
by the apostles for the purpose of ministering to the poor.843 Clement of Alexandria, in the
third book of his Stromata, relates the following things concerning him.844
This same story, with much more fullness of detail, is repeated by Epiphanius (Hær. XXX. 24), but of Ebion
(who never existed), instead of Cerinthus. This shows that the story was a very common one, while, at the same
time, so vague in its details as to admit of an application to any heretic who suited the purpose. That somebody
met somebody in a bath seems quite probable, and there is nothing to prevent our accepting the story as it stands
in Irenæus, if we choose to do so. One thing, at least, is certain, that Cerinthus is a historical character, who in
all probability was, for at least a part of his life, contemporary with John, and thus associated with him in tradition,
whether or not he ever came into personal contact with him.
842 Rev. ii. 6, 15. Salmon, in his article Nicolaitans, in the Dict. of Christ. Biog., states, as I think, quite correctly,
that “there really is no trustworthy evidence of the continuance of a sect so called after the death of the apostle
John”; and in this he is in agreement with many modern scholars. An examination of extant accounts of this
sect seems to show that nothing more was known of the Nicolaitans by any of the Fathers than what is told in
the Apocalypse. Justin, whose lost work against heretics Irenæus follows in his description of heresies, seems to
have made no mention of the Nicolaitans, for they are dragged in by Irenæus at the close of the text, quite out
of their chronological place. Irenæus (I. 26. 3; III. 11. 1) seems to have made up his account from the Apocalypse,
and to have been the sole source for later writers upon this subject. That the sect was licentious is told us by the
Apocalypse. That Nicolas, one of the Seven, was their founder is stated by Irenæus (I. 26. 3), Hippolytus (VII.
24), Pseudo-Tertullian (Adv. omnes Hær. chap. 1), and Epiphanius (Hær. 25), the last two undoubtedly drawing
their account from Hippolytus, and he in turn from Irenæus. Jerome and the writers of his time and later accept
this view, believing that Nicolas became licentious and fell into the greatest wickedness. Whether the sect really
claimed Nicolas as their founder, or whether the combination was made by Irenæus in consequence of the
identity of his name with the name of a sect mentioned in the Apocalypse, we cannot tell; nor have we any idea,
in the latter case, where the sect got the name which they bore. Clement of Alexandria, in the passage quoted
just below, gives us quite a different account of the character of Nicolas; and as he is a more reliable writer than
the ones above quoted, and as his statement explains excellently the appeal of the sect to Nicolas’ authority,
without impeaching his character, which certainly his position among the Seven would lead us to expect was
good, and good enough to warrant permanence, we feel safe in accepting his account as the true one, and
denying that Nicolas himself bore the character which marked the sect of the Nicolaitans; though the latter may,
as Clement says, have arisen from abusing a saying of Nicolas which had been uttered with a good motive.
843 See Acts vi
844 Stromata, III. 4.
Nicolaus and the Sect named after him.
340
Nicolaus and the Sect named after him.