2. Certain persons find fault with me because in the
books which I have written against Jovinian I have been excessive (so
they say) in praise of virginity and in depreciation of marriage; and
they affirm that to preach up chastity till no comparison is left
between a wife and a virgin is equivalent to a condemnation of
matrimony. If I remember aright the point of the dispute, the question
at issue between myself and Jovinian is that he puts marriage on a
level with virginity, while I make it inferior; he declares that there
is little or no difference between the two states, I assert that there
is a great deal. Finally—a result due under God to your
agency—he has been condemned because he has dared to set
matrimony on an equality with perpetual chastity. Or, if a virgin and a
wife are to be looked on as the same, how comes it that Rome has
refused to listen to this impious doctrine? A virgin owes her being to
a man, but a man does not owe his to a virgin. There can be no middle
course. Either my view of the matter must be embraced, or else that of
Jovinian. If I am blamed for putting wedlock below virginity, he must be praised for
putting the two states on a level. If, on the other hand, he is
condemned for supposing them equal, his condemnation must be taken as
testimony in favor of my treatise. If men of the world chafe under the
notion that they occupy a position inferior to that of virgins, I
wonder that clergymen and monks—who both live celibate
lives—refrain from praising what they consistently practise. They
cut themselves off from their wives to imitate the chastity of virgins,
and yet they will have it that married women are as good as these. They
should either be joined again to their wives whom they have renounced,
or, if they persist in living apart from them, they will have to
confess—by their lives if not by their words—that, in
preferring virginity to marriage, they have chosen the better course.
Am I then a mere novice in the Scriptures, reading the sacred volumes
for the first time? And is the line there drawn between virginity and
marriage so fine that I have been unable to observe it? I could know
nothing, forsooth, of the saying, “Be not righteous
overmuch!” Eccl. vii. 16: see Ag. Jov. i. 14. Thus, while I
try to protect myself on one side, I am wounded on the other; to speak
more plainly still, while I close with Jovinian in hand-to-hand combat,
Manichæus stabs me in the back. Have I not, I would ask, in the
very forefront of my work set the following preface: Against Jov. i.
3. “We are no disciples of Marcion A Gnostic presbyter of
the second century who rejected the Old Testament. or of Manichæus, An Eastern teacher of
the third century, a.d., the main feature of
whose system was its uncompromising dualism. to
detract from marriage. Nor are we deceived by the error of Tatian, A Syrian rhetorician
converted to Christianity by Justin Martyr. He wrote a harmony of the
Gospels called Diatessaron. the chief of the Encratites, I.e.
“the abstainers,” or “the continent,” a Gnostic
sect in the second century. into supposing all cohabitation unclean.
For he condemns and reprobates not marriage only, but foods also which
God has created for us to enjoy. 1 Tim. iv. 3. We know that
in a large house there are vessels not only of silver and of gold, but
of wood also and of earth. 2 Tim. ii. 20. We know, too, that
on the foundation of Christ which Paul the master builder has laid,
some build up gold, silver, and precious stones; others, on the
contrary, hay, wood, and stubble. 1 Cor. iii. 10–12. We are not
ignorant that ‘marriage is honorable…and the bed
undefiled.’ Heb. xiii. 4. We have read the
first decree of God: ‘Be fruitful and multiply and replenish the
earth.’ Gen. i. 28. But while we
allow marriage, we prefer the virginity which springs from it. Gold is
more precious than silver, but is silver on that account the less
silver? Is it an insult to a tree to prefer its apples to its roots or
its leaves? Is it an injury to corn to put the ear before the stalk and
the blade? As apples come from the tree and grain from the straw, so
virginity comes from wedlock. Yields of one hundredfold, of sixtyfold,
and of thirtyfold Matt. xiii. 8. may all come from
one soil and from one sowing, yet they will differ widely in quantity.
The yield thirtyfold signifies wedlock, for the joining together of the
fingers to express that number, suggestive as it is of a loving gentle
kiss or embracing, aptly represents the relation of husband and wife.
The yield sixtyfold refers to widows who are placed in a position of
distress and tribulation. Accordingly, they are typified by that finger
which is placed under the other to express the number sixty; for, as it
is extremely trying when one has once tasted pleasure to abstain from
its enticements, so the reward of doing this is proportionately great.
Moreover, a hundred—I ask the reader to give me his best
attention—necessitates a change from the left hand to the right;
but while the hand is different the fingers are the same as those which
on the left hand signify married women and widows; only in this
instance the circle formed by them indicates the crown of
virginity.” From this passage
compared with Ep. cxxiii. 9, and Bede De Temporum Ratione, c. 1. (De
Loquetâ Digitorum), it appears that the number thirty was
indicated by joining the tips of the thumb and forefinger of the left
hand, sixty was indicated by curling up the forefinger of the same hand
and then doubling the thumb over it, while one hundred was expressed by
joining the tips of the thumb and forefinger of the right hand. See
Prof. Mayor’s learned note on Juv. x. 249.