We hear our Lord saying.
“I and My Father are one,” and we are taught in that
utterance the dependence of our Lord on a cause, and yet the absolute
identity of the Son’s and the Father’s nature; we do not
let our idea about them be melted down into One Person, but we keep
distinct the properties of the Persons, while, on the other hand, not
dividing in the Persons the oneness of their substance; and so the
supposition of two diverse principles in the category of Cause is
avoided, and there is no loophole for the Manichæan heresy to
enter. For the created and the uncreate are as diametrically opposed to
each other as their names are; and so if the two are to be ranked as
First Causes, the mischief of Manichæism will thus under cover be
brought into the Church. I say this, because my zeal against our
antagonists makes me scrutinize their doctrine very closely. Now I
think that none would deny that we were bringing this scrutiny very
near the truth, when we said, that if the created be possessed of equal
power with the uncreate, there will be some sort of
antagonism between these things of diverse nature, and as long as
neither of them fails in power, the two will be brought into a certain
state of mutual discord for we must perforce allow that will
corresponds with, and is intimately joined to nature; and that if two
things are unlike in nature, they will be so also in will. But when
power is adequate in both, neither will flag in the gratification of
its wish; and if the power of each is thus equal to its wish, the
primacy will become a doubtful point with the two: and it will end in a
drawn battle from the inexhaustibleness of their powers. Thus will the
Manichæan heresy creep in, two opposite principles appearing with
counter claims in the category of Cause, parted and opposed by reason
of difference both in nature and in will. They will find, therefore,
that assertion of diminution (in the Divine being) is the beginning of
Manichæism; for their teaching organizes a discord within that
being, which comes to two leading principles, as our account of it has
shewn; namely the created and the uncreated.