PHILOSOPHY
meaning which is really intended by Ferrier. When, however,
this has become clear, it also becomes clear that the apparent
advance to an important new position is illusory. What has
been gained is not so much due to deductive inference as to a more
precise and full definition of the meaning of the original proposi-
tion. Where this is not the case, it will be generally found that
there is a fallacy in the reasoning. Thus the deductive form
of the work is in the main a mere formality, and contributes
little or nothing to its value. Wherein, then, does its value
consist ? I have already indicated the answer to this question.
Both the leading merit and the chief defect of Ferrier's
work is bound up with his practice of continually saying virtually
the same thing over again in new forms and in varying contexts.
There were certain fundamental postulateswhich formed the light
of all his seeing ; these postulates are constantly kept in view
throughout his writings, so that their full significance is gradually
disclosed ; the attentive reader is thus compelled to examine
them and re-examine them in their various bearings and applica-
tions, so that he becomes gradually penetrated with a full and
vivid realisation of their meaning and importance. Whether
he ends by accepting or rejecting, he will at least know clearly
and distinctly what it is that he accepts or rejects.
We may illustrate by considering the main thesis of Ferrier's
philosophy. This is formulated as follows in the first
proposition of the Institutes :
" Along with whatever any
intelligence knows, it must, as the ground or condition of its
knowledge, have some cognisance of itself." The proposition,
if it is to be made the basis of a chain of deductive reasoning,
ought at least to be unambiguously stated in the sense which it
is intended to bear throughout its subsequent applications. But
this is not the case. On the contrary, the sense which the
wording of the original statement, prima facie, conveys is not
that which turns out to be most important for the development of
159