Book I. The treatise
begins with St. Hilary’s own spiritual history, the events of
which are displayed, no doubt, more logically and symmetrically in the
narrative than they had occurred in the writer’s
experience. He tells of the efforts of a pure and noble soul,
impeded, so far as we hear, neither by unworthy desires nor by
indifference, to find an adequate end and aim of life. He rises
first to the conception of the old philosophers, and then by successive
advances, as he learns more and more of the Divine revelation in
Scripture, he attains the object of his search in the apprehension of
God as revealed in the Catholic Faith. But this happiness is not
the result of a mere intellectual knowledge, but of belief as
well. In §§ 1–14 we have this advance from
ignorance and fear to knowledge and peace. And here he might have
rested, had he not been charged with the sacerdotal (i.e., in the
language of that time, the episcopal) office, which laid upon him the
duty of caring for the salvation of others. And such care was
needed, for (§§ 15, 16) heresies were abroad, and chiefly
two; the Sabellian which said that Father and Son were mere names or
aspects of one Divine Person, and therefore there had been no true
birth of the Son; and the Arian (which, however, Hilary rarely calls by
the name of its advocate, preferring to style it the ‘new
heresy’) asserting more or less openly that the Son is created
and not born, and therefore is different in kind from the Father, and
not, in the true sense, God. Hilary declares (§ 17) that his
purpose is to refute these heresies and to demonstrate the true faith
by the evidence of Scripture. He demands from his hearers a loyal
belief in the Scriptures which he will cite; without such faith his
arguments will not profit them (§ 18); and in § 19 he warns
them of the limits of the argument from analogy, which he must employ,
inadequate as it is in respect of the finite illustrations which he
must use to express the infinite. Then in § 20 he speaks
with a modest pride of his careful marshalling of the arguments which
shall lead his readers to the right conclusion, and in §§
21–36 he gives a summary of the contents of the work. He
concludes the first Book (§§ 37, 38) with a prayer which
expresses his certainty that what he holds is the truth, and entreats
the Father and the Son that he may have the eloquence of language and
the cogency of reasoning needed for the worthy presentation of the
truth concerning Them.