Florinus, as we learn from chap. 15, was for a time a presbyter of
the Roman Church, but lost his office on account of heresy. From the
fragment of this epistle of Irenæus to Florinus quoted by Eusebius
just below, we learn that Florinus was somewhat older than
Irenæus, but like him a disciple of Polycarp. The title of this
epistle shows that Florinus was already a Gnostic, or at least inclined
toward Gnostic views. Eusebius evidently had no direct knowledge of the
opinions of Florinus on the origin of evil, for he says that he
appeared to maintain (ἐδόκει
προασπίζειν) the opinion that God was the author of evil.
Eusebius’ conclusion is accepted by most ancient and modern
writers, but it is suggested by Salmon (Dict. of Christ. Biog.
II. 544) that Eusebius was perhaps mistaken, “for, since the
characteristic of dualism is not to make God the author of evil, but to
clear him from the charge by ascribing evil to an independent origin,
the title would lead us to think that the letter was directed, not
against one who had himself held God to be the author of evil, but
against one who had charged the doctrine of a single first principle
with necessarily leading to this conclusion. And we should have
supposed that the object of Irenæus was to show that it was
possible to assert God to be the sole origin and ruler of the universe,
without holding evil to be his work.” Since Eusebius had seen the
epistle of Irenæus to Florinus, it is difficult to understand how
he can have misconceived Florinus’ position. At the same time, he
does not state it with positiveness; and the fact that Florinus, if not
already, certainly was soon afterward a Valentinian, and hence a
dualist, makes Salmon’s supposition very plausible. Florinus is
not mentioned in Irenæus’ great work against heresies, nor
by Tertullian, Pseudo-Tertullian, Hippolytus, or Epiphanius. It is
probable, therefore, that he was not named in Hippolytus’ earlier
work, nor in the lectures of Irenæus which formed the groundwork
(see Salmon, l.c.). The silence of Irenæus is easily
explained by supposing Florinus’ fall into heresy to have taken
place after the composition of his lectures against heresies and of his
great work; and the silence of the later writers is probably due to the
fact that Irenæus’ work makes no mention of him and that,
whatever his influence may have been during his lifetime, it did not
last, and hence his name attracted no particular attention after his
death.
It has been maintained
by some (e.g. Lightfoot in the Contemporary Review, 1875, p.
834) that this epistle to Florinus was one of the earliest of
Irenæus’ writings but Lipsius (Dict. of Christ. Biog.
III. 263) has given other and satisfactory reasons for thinking that
Florinus’ heresy, and therefore Irenæus’ epistle and
his work On the Ogdoad, belonged to the time of Victor, and
hence were later than the work Against Heresies. A Syriac
fragment of an epistle concerning Florinus, addressed by Irenæus
to Victor (Harvey’s edition, Fragm. 28), is extant, and supports
Lipsius’ conclusion. It would seem that Irenæus, subsequent
to the writing of his great work, learning that Florinus was holding
heretical opinions on the origin of evil, addressed him the epistle
mentioned in this chapter. That afterward, Florinus having embraced
Valentinianism, and having written “an abominable book” (as
the fragment just referred to says), Irenæus wrote his work On
the Ogdoad, and subsequently addressed his epistle to Victor,
calling upon him to take decisive measures against Florinus, now seen
to be a regular heretic. What was the result of Irenæus’
epistles and book we do not know; we hear nothing more about the
matter, nor do we know anything more about Florinus (for
Augustine’s mention of Florinus as the founder of a sect of
Floriniani is a mistake; see Salmon, l.c.).