1. The Ario-maniacs, as
it appears, having once made up their minds to transgress and revolt
from the Truth, are strenuous in appropriating the words of Scripture,
‘When the impious cometh into a depth of evils, he despiseth Prov. xviii.
3,
LXX.;’ for refutation does not stop them,
nor perplexity abash them; but, as having ‘a whore’s
forehead,’ they ‘refuse to be ashamed Jer. iii. 3.’ before all men in their irreligion.
For whereas the passages which they alleged, ‘The Lord created
me Supr. ch. xix.,’ and ‘Made better than the
Angels Ch.
xiii.,’ and ‘First-born Ch.
xxi.,’ and ‘Faithful to Him that made
Him Ch.
xiv.’ have a right sense ii.
44, n. 1., and inculcate religiousness towards Christ,
so it is that these men still, as if bedewed with the serpent’s
poison, not seeing what they ought to see, nor understanding what they
read, as if in vomit from the depth of their irreligious heart, have
next proceeded to disparage our Lord’s words, ‘I in the
Father and the Father in Me John xiv. 10.;’ saying,
‘How can the One be contained in the Other and the Other in the
One?’ or ‘How at all can the Father who is the greater be
contained in the Son who is the less?’ or ‘What wonder, if
the Son is in the Father,’ considering it is written even of us,
‘In Him we live and move and have our being Acts xvii. 28. Vid.
supr. ii. 41, note 11. The doctrine of the περιχώρησις, which this objection introduces, is the test of orthodoxy
opposed to Arianism. Cf. de Syn. 15, n. 4. This is seen clearly
in the case of Eusebius, whose language approaches to Catholic more
nearly than Arians in general. After all his strong assertions, the
question recurs, is our Lord a distinct being from God, as we are, or
not? he answers in the affirmative, vid. supr. p. 75, n. 7,
whereas we believe that He is literally and numerically one with the
Father, and therefore His Person dwells in the Father’s Person by
an ineffable union. And hence the language of Dionysius [of Rome]
supr. de Decr. 26. ‘the Holy Ghost must repose and
habitate in God,’ ἐμφιλοχωρεῖν
τῷ θεῷ καὶ
ἐνδιαιτᾶσθαι. And hence the strong figure of S. Jerome (in which he is
followed by S. Cyril, Thesaur. p. 51), ‘Filius locus est
Patris, sicut et Pater locus est Filii.’ in Ezek. iii. 12. So Athan.
contrasts the creatures who are ἐν
μεμερισμένοις
τόποις and the
Son. Serap. iii. 4. Cf. even in the Macrostich Creed, language
of this character, viz. ‘All the Father embosoming the Son, and
all the Son hanging and adhering to the Father, and alone resting on
the Father’s breast continually.’ De Syn. 26 (7),
where vid. note 3.?’ And this state of mind is consistent
with their perverseness, who think God to be material, and understand
not what is ‘True
Father’ and ‘True Son,’ nor ‘Light
Invisible’ and ‘Eternal,’ and Its ‘Radiance
Invisible,’ nor ‘Invisible Subsistence,’ and
‘Immaterial Expression’ and ‘Immaterial Image.’
For did they know, they would not dishonour and ridicule the Lord of
glory, nor interpreting things immaterial after a material manner,
pervert good words. It were sufficient indeed, on hearing only words
which are the Lord’s, at once to believe, since the faith of
simplicity is better than an elaborate process of persuasion; but since
they have endeavoured to profane even this passage to their own heresy,
it becomes necessary to expose their perverseness and to shew the mind
of the truth, at least for the security of the faithful. For when it is
said, ‘I in the Father and the Father in Me,’ They are not
therefore, as these suppose, discharged into Each Other, filling the
One the Other, as in the case of empty vessels, so that the Son fills
the emptiness of the Father and the Father that of the Son This
is not inconsistent with S. Jerome as quoted in the foregoing note.
Athan. merely means that such illustrations cannot be taken literally,
as if spoken of natural subjects. The Father is the τόπος or locus of the Son, because when we contemplate the Son in His
fulness as ὅλος
θεός, we merely view the
Father as that Person in whom God the Son is; our mind abstracts His
Essence which is the Son for the moment from Him, and regards Him
merely as Father. Thus in Illud. Omn. 4, supr. p.
89. It is, however, but an operation of the mind, and not a real
emptying of Godhead from the Father, if such words may be used. Father
and Son are both the same God, though really and eternally distinct
from each other; and Each is full of the Other, that is, their Essence
is one and the same. This is insisted on by S. Cyril, in Joan.
p. 28. And by S. Hilary, Trin. vii. fin. vid. also iii. 23. Cf.
the quotation from S. Anselm made by Petavius, de Trin. iv. 16
fin. [Cf. D.C.B. s.v. Metangismonitae.], and Each of Them by Himself is not complete
and perfect (for this is proper to bodies, and therefore the mere
assertion of it is full of irreligion), for the Father is full and
perfect, and the Son is the Fulness of Godhead. Nor again, as God, by
coming into the Saints, strengthens them, thus is He also in the Son.
For He is Himself the Father’s Power and Wisdom, and by partaking
of Him things originate are sanctified in the Spirit; but the Son
Himself is not Son by participation, but is the Father’s own
Offspring Vid.
de Decr. 10, n. 4, 19, n. 3; Or. i. 15, n. 6. On the
other hand Eusebius considers the Son, like a creature, ἐξ
αὐτῆς τῆς
πατρικῆς [not οὐσίας,
but] μετουσίας,
ὥσπερ ἀπὸ
πηγῆς, ἐπ᾽
αὐτὸν
προχεομένης
πληρούμενον. Eccl. Theol. i. 2. words which are the more
observable, the nearer they approach to the language of Athan. in the
text and elsewhere. Vid. infr. by way of contrast, οὐδὲ
κατὰ
μετουσίαν
αὐτοῦ, ἀλλ᾽
ὅλον ἴδιον
αὐτοῦ
γέννημα.
4.. Nor again is the Son in the Father,
in the sense of the passage, ‘In Him we live and move and have
our being;’ for, He as being from the Fount De
Decr. 15, n. 9. of the Father is the Life, in which all
things are both quickened and consist; for the Life does not live in
life i.e.
Son does not live by the gift of life, for He is life,
and does but give it, not receive. S. Hilary uses different language
with the same meaning, de Trin. ii. 11. Other modes of
expression for the same mystery are found infr. 3. also 6 fin.
Vid. de Syn. 45, n. 1. and Didymus ἡ πατρικὴ
θεότης. p. 82.
and S. Basil, ἐξ οὗ ἔχει
τὸ εἶναι.
contr. Eunom. ii. 12 fin. Just above Athan. says that
‘the Son is the fulness of the Godhead.’ Thus the Father is
the Son’s life because the Son is from Him, and the Son the
Father’s because the Son is in Him. All these are but different
ways of signifying the περιχώρησις, else it would not be Life, but rather He
gives life to all things.