But in the Intelligible
world,—that part of it, I mean, which is created,—the idea
of such differences as are perceived in the Sensible cannot find a
place: another method, then, is devised for discovering the degrees of
greater and less. The fountain, the origin, the supply of every good is
regarded as being in the world that is uncreate, and the whole creation
inclines to that, and touches and shares the Highest Existence only by
virtue of its part in the First Good: therefore it follows from this
participation in the highest blessings varying in degree according to
the amount of freedom in the will that each possesses, that the greater
and less in this creation is disclosed according to the proportion of
this tendency in each i.e.
according as each inclines more or less to the First Good.. Created intelligible
nature stands on the borderline between good and the reverse, so as to
be capable of either, and to incline at pleasure to the things of its
choice, as we learn from Scripture; so that we can say of it that it is
more or less in the heights of excellence only in proportion to its
removal from the evil and its approach to the good. Whereas uncreate intelligible nature is far removed from such
distinctions. This was the impregnable
position that Athanasius had taken up. To admit that the Son is less
than the Father, and the Spirit less than the Son, is to admit the
law of emanation such as hitherto conceived, that is, the gradual
and successive degradation of God’s substance; which had
conducted oriental heretics as well as the Neoplatonists to a sort of
pantheistic polytheism. Arius had indeed tried to resist this tendency
so far as to bring back divinity to the Supreme Being; but it was at
the expense of the divinity of the Son, Who was with him just as much a
created Intermediate between God and man, as one of the Æons: and
Aetius and Eunomius treated the Holy Ghost also as their master had
treated the Son. But Arianism tended at once to Judaism and, in making
creatures adorable, to Greek polytheism. There was only one way of
cutting short the phantasmagoria of divine emanations, without having
recourse to the contradictory hypothesis of Arius: and that was to
reject the law of emanation, as hitherto accepted, altogether.
Far from admitting that the Supreme Being is always weakening and
degrading Himself in that which emanates from Him, Athanasius lays down
the principle that He produces within Himself nothing but what is
perfect, and first, and divine: and all that is not perfect is a work
of the Divine Will, which draws it out of nothing (i.e. creates it),
and not out of the Divine Substance. This was the crowning result of
the teaching of Alexandria and Origen. See Denys (De la Philosophie
d’Origene, p. 432, Paris, 1884). uncreate intelligible nature is far removed
from such distinctions: it does not possess the good by
acquisition, or participate only in the goodness of some good which
lies above it: in its own essence it is good, and is conceived as such:
it is a source of good, it is simple, uniform, incomposite, even by the
confession of our adversaries. But it has distinction within itself in
keeping with the majesty of its own nature, but not conceived of with
regard to quantity, as Eunomius supposes: (indeed the man who
introduces the notion of less of good into any of the things believed
to be in the Holy Trinity must admit thereby some admixture of the
opposite quality in that which fails of the good: and it is blasphemous
to imagine this in the case either of the Only-begotten, or of the Holy
Spirit): we regard it as consummately perfect and incomprehensibly
excellent yet as containing clear distinctions within itself which
reside in the peculiarities of each of the Persons: as possessing
invariableness by virtue of its common attribute of uncreatedness, but
differentiated by the unique character of each Person. This peculiarity
contemplated in each sharply and clearly divides one from the other:
the Father, for instance, is uncreate and ungenerate as well: He was
never generated any more than He was created. While this uncreatedness
is common to Him and the Son, and the Spirit, He is ungenerate as well
as the Father. This is peculiar and uncommunicable, being not seen in
the other Persons. The Son in His uncreatedness touches the Father and
the Spirit, but as the Son and the Only-begotten He has a character
which is not that of the Almighty or of the Holy Spirit. The Holy
Spirit by the uncreatedness of His nature has contact with the Son and
Father, but is distinguished from them by His own tokens. His most
peculiar characteristic is that He is neither of those things which we
contemplate in the Father and the Son respectively. He is
simply, neither as ungenerate But He
is not begotten. Athanasian Creed., nor as
only-begotten: this it is that constitutes His chief peculiarity.
Joined to the Father by His uncreatedness, He is disjoined from Him
again by not being ‘Father.’ United to the Son by the bond
of uncreatedness, and of deriving His existence from the Supreme, He is
parted again from Him by the characteristic of not being the
Only-begotten of the Father, and of having been manifested by means of
the Son Himself. Again, as the creation was effected by the
Only-begotten, in order to secure that the Spirit should not be
considered to have something in common with this creation because of
His having been manifested by means of the Son, He is distinguished
from it by His unchangeableness, and independence of all external
goodness. The creation does not possess in its nature this
unchangeableness, as the Scripture says in the description of the fall
of the morning star, the mysteries on which subject are revealed by our
Lord to His disciples: “I saw Satan falling like lightning from
heaven Luke x. 18..” But the very attributes which part
Him from the creation constitute His relationship to the Father and the
Son. All that is incapable of degenerating has one and the same
definition of “unchangeable.”