56 MEMORIALS OF TWO SISTERS [1850-1
shuffling, and had a true right to be in the Church. I had
always had an uneasy feeling that he probably stayed in it
by some such excuses as Dr. Arnold framed for himself, and
it warms my heart to find how true he is. Only when he
speaks with a sort of wonder as to the reasons why laymen
allow so much more latitude of interpretation to clergymen
than they would ever use themselves, I wonder why he does
not see that it is a necessary consequence of the clergymen
being obliged to sign all these formularies ; since they all
sign the same things and certainly don't all believe the
same things, it is the most charitable way of accounting for
the phenomenon. It is strange that he does not see that
this is a very strong argument against tests, while he depicts
the abuse that has crept in through them so clearly.
Then, though the doctrine of baptismal regeneration as
he holds it (Whately, too, holds the same or something
very like it) is a doctrine very easy to understand any one's
holding in itself, I never comprehend the Scripture proofs ;
perhaps because I have not studied the Scriptures con-
troversially. And then, finally, though I quite see what an
advantage it gives Mr. Maurice in addressing men who,
though baptized, are not converted, to feel that he has this
tie of brotherhood with them, and to make them feel it ;
yet I cannot tell what he does when he comes to Dissenters ;
and I should like to know whether the doctrine exerts any
practical influence on his feelings towards pious Dissenters
for instance, or towards unbaptized Theists, or whether, in
such cases,he falls back on the wider bond that he and they
are children of one Father, and feels that enough to unite
them. I can fancy that he would do so with a good Deist,
but I can less understand his position towards a good
Dissenter, whom surely he cannot look on otherwise than
as belonging to Christ's Church, a fellow-Christian with
himself, and equally assisted by God's Spirit.
I wish I could more clearly understand the intellectual
position of such men as he and Mr. Kingsley ; so much of
what they say about the Church and about our Lord I like,
but I do not see how it all fits together. There is to me,