that time written a treatise against the Jews, and also to others who had attempted to vilify
the hereditary institutions of the Jewish people.
5. In the first of these books he gives the number of the canonical books of the so-called
Old Testament. Apparently674 drawing his information from ancient tradition, he shows
what books were accepted without dispute among the Hebrews. His words are as follows.
and which is mentioned by no one else. The other works planned by Josephus—On God and his Essence (Ant.
XX. 11. 3), and On the Laws of the Jews (ibid. and Ant. III. 5. 6, 8. 10)—seem never to have been written. (They
are mentioned also by Eusebius in the next chapter.) Other compositions attributed to him are not from his
hand. The best edition of the works of Josephus is that of Benedict Niese (Berlin, 1885 sq.), of which the first
two volumes have been already issued, comprising ten books of the Antiquities. A good complete edition is that
of Dindorf (Paris, 1845–47, 2 vols.). That of Bekker (Leipzig, 1855, 6 vols.) is very convenient. The only complete
English translation is by Whiston, unfortunately uncritical and inaccurate. Traill’s translation of the Jewish War
(London, 1862) is a great improvement, but does not cover the remainder of Josephus’ works. Upon Josephus
and his writings, see the article of Edersheim in the Dict. of Christ. Biog. III. 441–460, and compare the literature
given there.
674 ὡσ€ν.
283
Josephus and the Works which he has left.