All these considerations seem to me of insufficient
strength, or mere conjecture, to make an alteration in the text, and
arbitrarily to remove the name of Origen. As regards the
objection in connection with Theodore Ascidas, it is known that the
latter had already pronounced a formal anathema on Origen, and
certainly he did the same this time, if the Emperor wished it or if it
seemed advisable. The second and fourth objections have little
weight. In regard to the third (c) it is quite possible that
either the Emperor subsequently went further than in his ὁμολογία, or
that the bishops at the fifth Synod, of their own accord, added Origen,
led on perhaps by one or another anti-Origenist of their number.
What, however, chiefly determines us to the retention of the text
is: (a) that the copy of the synodal Acts extant in the Roman
archives, which has the highest credibility, and was probably prepared
for Vigilius himself, contains the name of Origen in the eleventh
anathematism; and (b) that the monks of the new Lama in Palestine, who
are known to have been zealous Origenists, withdrew Church communion
from the bishops of Palestine after these had subscribed the Acts of
the fifth Synod. In the anathema on the Three Chapters these
Origenists could find as little ground for such a rupture as their
friends and former colleague Ascidas; it could only be by the synod
attacking their darling Origen. (c) Finally, only on the ground
that the name of Origen really stood in the eleventh anathematism, can
we explain the widely-circulated ancient rumour that our Synod
anathematized Origen and the Origenists.