The dogmatic standpoint, as we have seen, was
traditionalism, toward which the Church gravitated under the dictation
of the councils, the influence of bishops like Athanasius, the almost
uniform ictus of the Roman see, Ambrose, the Gregories, Basil the
Great, Ephraim, Eusebius, and Epiphanius, the majority of monks, and
finally the whole force of the State. He opposes all shades of
Arianism, as also Apolinarianism; had he completed his work, from what
he says of Pulcheria’s conquest over heresies, he would have
opposed the Nestorian views of the Theotokos. But of Donatism and
Cyprianism he has not a word. Of the anthropological struggles of the
West there is not a syllable. Here is the place, also, to consider his
attitude toward heresies. Sozomen does not assail any phase of Arianism
with the intemperate epithets which Eusebius employed to condemn the
earlier innovators, or such as abound in Theodoret and Evagrius and
later historians. Indeed, he sometimes calls them Christians and
members of the Catholic Church. His treatment of the Novatians, while a
little offish, is yet generous as compared with other writers, except
Socrates, from whom he obtains almost all their history; he devotes
much space; he is generally courteous in tone; and when he speaks of
the proposed union (iv. 2) between the Catholic Church and that body of
believers, he omits the cause of the failure; viz., the reluctance of
some legalistic Novatians to acquiesce,—a point which Socrates
does not fail to expose. He mentions Montanism (Phrygianism) several
times, but with no new facts, save that they were numerous in Phrygia
in his day, and had peculiar Paschal usages (i. 6, ii. 18, 32, vii. 18,
19). Of the Gnostic sects, he alludes to the Valentinians only, whose
conventicles were repressed by an edict of Constantius (ii. 32). The
Manichæans are mentioned only as they are one of the three sects
excepted from Gratian’s law of toleration (vii. 1). Of the
Pricillianists, whose attempt at a world religion falls so wholly
within his time, he says nothing. The Quartodecimanians are still
numerous and tenacious (vii. 18). He has a bare allusion to the
Encratites (v. 11). Of the Origenistic controversy, he has no more to
say than he is compelled to, in order to state correctly the conflict
between Theophilus and Chrysostom. Over against the Origenists he
places the Anthropomorphists (viii. 12). Of Lucifer’s separatism,
he gives only the rise (iii. 15). With all his emphatic adherence to
the current orthodoxy, he must be regarded as the most charitable of
historians next to Socrates. Mention has already been made of his
kindly disposition toward the Novatians. When writing fully and
favorably, as was his duty, about Aëtius (iii. 15), he is
constrained to make an apology: “Let it not be accounted strange
if I have bestowed commendations upon the leaders or enthusiasts of the
above-mentioned heresies. I admire their eloquence and their
impressiveness in discourse: I leave their doctrines to be judged by
those whose prerogative it is.”