Chapter 53.—101. The question is also commonly raised, whether baptism is to be held
valid which is received from one who had not himself received it, if, from some promptings
of curiosity, he had chanced to learn how it ought to be conferred; and whether it makes no
difference in what spirit the recipient receives it, whether in mockery or in sincerity: if in
mockery, whether the difference arises when the mockery is of deceit, as in the Church, or
in what is thought to be the Church; or when it is in jest, as in a play: and which is the more
513
accursed, to receive it deceitfully in the Church, or in heresy or schism without deceit, that
is to say, with full sincerity of heart: or whether it be worse to receive it deceitfully in heresy
or in good faith in a play, if any one were to be moved by a sudden feeling of religion in the
midst of his acting. And yet, if we compare such an one even with him who receives it de-
ceitfully in the Catholic Church itself, I should be surprised if any one were to doubt which
of the two should be preferred; for I do not see of what avail the intention of him who gives
in truth can be to him who receives deceitfully. But let us consider, in the case of some one
also giving it in deceit, when both the given and the recipient are acting deceitfully in the
unity of the Catholic Church itself, whether this should rather be acknowledged as baptism,
or that which is given in a play, if any one should be found who received it faithfully from
a sudden impulse of religion: or whether it be not true that, so far as the men themselves
are concerned, there is a very great difference between the believing recipient in a play, and
the mocking recipient in the Church; but that in regard to the genuineness of the sacrament
there is no difference. For if it makes no difference in respect to the genuineness of the
sacrament within the Catholic Church itself, whether certain persons celebrate it in truth
or in deceit, so long as both still celebrate the same thing, I cannot see why it should make
a difference outside, seeing that he who receives it is not cloaked by his deceit, but he is
changed by his religious impulse. Or have those truthful persons among whom it is celebrated
more power for the confirmation of the sacrament, than those deceitful men by whom and
in whom it is celebrated can exert for its invalidation? And yet, if the deceit be subsequently
brought to light, no one seeks a repetition of the sacrament; but the fraud is either punished
by excommunication or set right by penitence.
102. But the safe course for us is, not to advance with any rashness of judgment in setting
forth a view which has neither been started in any regionary Council of the Catholic Church
nor established in a plenary one; but to assert, with all the confidence of a voice that cannot
be gainsaid, what has been confirmed by the consent of the universal Church, under the
direction of our Lord God and Saviour Jesus Christ. Nevertheless, if any one were to press
me—supposing I were duly seated in a Council in which a question were raised on points
like these—to declare what my own opinion was, without reference to the previously ex-
pressed views of others, whose judgment I would rather follow, if I were under the influence
of the same feelings as led me to assert what I have said before, I should have no hesitation
in saying that all men possess baptism who have received it in any place, from any sort of
Chapter 53
975
Chapter 53