The relation of Church and State involves the question
of persecution. It is not the history of the endeavor to enforce
uniformity, with which we shall concern ourselves, but rather the views
Sozomen sets forth, as to the policy of repression. The laws of
Constantine suppressing heretics did not affect the Novatians (ii. 32),
concerning which justice, he remarks: “The emperor, I believe,
willingly relaxed the rigor of the enactment in their favor, for he
only desired to strike terror into the minds of his subjects, and had
no intention of persecuting them.” The punishments inflicted in
Constantius’ time on the orthodox in Constantinople, both by
Macedonius (iv. 23) and Eudoxius (iv. 26), call forth this reflection:
“For, if the persecution did not occasion such tortures to the
body as preceding ones, it appeared more grievous to all who reflected
aright, on account of its disgraceful nature, for both the persecutors
and the persecuted belonged to the Church; and the one was all the more
disgraceful in that men of the same religion treated their fellows with
a degree of cruelty which the ecclesiastical laws prohibit to be
manifested towards enemies and strangers.” He spares himself the
pain of registering all who were ejected from their sees (iv. 27), for
no province was without its list of sufferers. The cruelties inflicted
by George on pagan and orthodox, furnish a mournful narrative (iv. 30).
On the elevation of Julian, a great dread fell upon the Christian
world, intensified by the portents which befell him. The series of
edicts soon wrought mutual dissension in the Christian ranks, as well
as suffering from without. But while Sozomen attributes the refinements
of cruelty to Julian, and lays the miseries of the saints at his door
as parts of a subtle plan, he nevertheless cannot conceal from himself
the absence of direct interference on the part of the State; these
calamities were the results of a restoration of the old religion to its
ancient union with the State; it was an imperial act; and he is
compelled to confess the seeming magnanimity of Julian in certain
cases, but even then maligns his motives. The imperial clemency did not
arise from any feeling of compassion, but because persecution would
only increase the number of Galilean adherents; because he was envious
of their glory, did he resort to argument instead of cruelty, and
manifest an unexpected benevolence instead of proceeding to rigorous
measures (v. 4, 5). “It may be concluded from what has been said,
that if Julian shed less blood than preceding persecutors of the
Church, and that if he devised fewer punishments for the torture of the
body, yet that he was severer in other respects.” Nevertheless,
this statement is followed by a record of suffering in all quarters of
the empire and the impression of purposed directness is given, as if
the State had inflicted them, especially when we read that the emperor
would not listen to the cautions of Sallust (v. 20). He does not
comment on Jovian’s toleration, but only rejoices in the return
of the Church to ascendancy. Unsparing is his picture of the dastardly
measures of Valens against the professors of the faith; he regards that
persecutor as the special victim of Divine wrath; while, on the other
hand, he does not hesitate to call the Arian Goths, who fell under the
anger of Athanaric, martyrs (vi. 37). He does not express an opinion as
to the partial toleration of Gratian’s edict (vii. 1); but in
explanation of Theodosius’ law forbidding heretics, i.e. all
anti-Nicenists, from holding churches and from exercising any clerical
function, he says: “Great as were the punishments adjudged by the laws against heretics, they
were not always carried into execution; for the emperor had no desire
to persecute his subjects; he only desired to enforce uniformity of
view about God’ through the medium of intimidation. Those who
voluntarily renounced heretical opinions, received commendation from
him.” And it is true that the court practice of persecuting
emperors, orthodox or Arian, was utterly in the teeth of their own
edicts, and their most intimate counselors were elected without regard
to religion. When Justina sought to revive the Arian standard in the
West, her treatment of Ambrose is called persecution (vii. 13); but
Ambrose’s intolerant procedures against the Arians are not even
noticed. No quizzical wrinkle disturbs the flow of his narrative in
vii. 15, when Theodosius I. gives a heathen temple to the Christians,
and the pagans resolve to defend their rights, and do so effectually;
but the Christians who perish in that hateful conflict are crowned as
martyrs by an imperial edict! For the religious tyranny of Theodosius
the Great he is a warm apologist, and disguises the perversion of that
principle of freedom for which he pleads most earnestly, when the
Arians hold the reins of power, and abuse their opportunity. The
contradictions are perfectly apparent and irreconcilable, because
uniformity by force has always been impossible. Yet logical men will
state the most contradictory reasons, which no quidnunc can refrain
from laughing at. Themistius’ plea for toleration (vi. 36) in
matters of intellectual belief, on the ground of secular diversities in
philosophy and from the incomprehensible nature of God, shows the
existence of a party who believed in this principle. While Sozomen
gives it place, and hailed the Gothic Arians who compelled Valens to
cease his oppressions, he has no word of approbation for the
proposition or the argument.