read in God’s word, of men’s being convinced of their wickedness, and confessing their sins,
as a way to be healed and cleansed from sin: but where do we read of men’s pretending to
more goodness than they have, and making a hypocritical profession and show of goodness,
in order to their becoming good men? 407 Where have we a divine institution, that any who
are wolves should put on sheep’s clothing, and so come to his people, that they may believe
them to be sheep, and under this notion receive them into the flock, to the end that they
may truly become of his sheep?
But to examine this matter, of the Lord’s supper being a converting ordinance to ungodly
men professing godliness, a little more exactly. If Christ has appointed the Lord’s supper to
be a converting ordinance to some such as these, then he has appointed it either only for
such of them as are mistaken, and think themselves godly when they are not; or he has ap-
pointed it not only for such, but also for such as are sensible they are ungodly.
If it be appointed as a converting ordinance only for such as are mistaken, and think
themselves converted; then here is an institution of Christ, which never can, in any one in-
stance, be made use of to the end for which he has appointed men to use it. It cannot be
used for this end by those who admit members, and administer the ordinance: for they, as
Mr. W. says, must admit none but such as they are bound by the rule of Christ to look upon
as godly men already, and to administer the sacrament to them under that notion, and with
respect to such a character. Neither can it be used to such a purpose by any of the commu-
nicants: for by the supposition, they must be all such as think they are converted already,
and also come under that notion. So that by this scheme of things, here is an institution ap-
pointed to be upheld and used in the church, which the institution itself makes void and
impossible. For, as was observed before, the notion of a converting ordinance has not refer-
ence to any secret decree of God, how he in his sovereign pleasure will sometimes use it; but
to his institution given to men, appointing the end for which they should use it. Therefore,
on the present supposition, the institution appoints the Lord’s supper to be used in some
cases for the conversion of sinners, but at the same time forbids its being either given or
received under any other notion than that of the communicant’s being converted already:
407 Mr. Williams (p. 42.) owns that persons must make a profession wherein they make a show of being wise
virgins, in order to come into the visible church. And (p. 35. e.) he owns, that all visible saints who are not truly
pious, are hypocrites. Again, it may be observed, he abundantly insists, that men who have no more than common
grace and moral sincerity, may lawfully come to sacraments; and yet by what he says, (p. 35. e.) they must profess
more. So that men who have no more must profess more; and this, it seems, according to divine institu-
tion!—Again he says, (p. 35. a. b. c.) That one end God designed by appointing men to be brought into the
church, is, that through divine grace they might effectually be brought to Christ, to give him the whole possession
of their hearts; and yet in the very next paragraph (p. 35. e. and 36. a.) he speaks of it as unlawful for men to
come to sacraments till they give up all their hearts to Christ.
1945
SECTION VII. A converting ordinance.