7. But it will be said, “If you knew these things,
why did you praise him in your works?” I should praise him today
but that you and men like you praise his errors. I should still find
his talent attractive, but that some people have been attracted by his
impiety. “Read A.V.
‘prove.’ all
things,” says the apostle, “hold fast that which is
good.” 1 Thess. v. 21. Lactantius in his books and
particularly in his letters to Demetrian altogether denies the
subsistence of the Holy Spirit, and following the error of the Jews
says that the passages in which he is spoken of refer to the Father or
to the Son and that the words ‘holy spirit’ merely prove
the holiness of these two persons
in the Godhead. But who can forbid me to read his
Institutes—in which he has written against the Gentiles
with much ability—simply because this opinion of his is to be
abhorred? Apollinaris See note on
§ 2 above. has written
excellent treatises against Porphyry, and I approve of his labours,
although I despise his doctrine in many points because of its
foolishness. If you too for your parts will but admit that Origen errs
in certain things I will not say another syllable. Acknowledge that he
thought amiss concerning the Son, and still more amiss concerning the
Holy Spirit, point out the impiety of which he has been guilty in
speaking of men’s souls as having fallen from heaven, and shew
that, while in word he asserts the resurrection of the flesh, he
destroys the force of this language by other assertions. As, for
instance, that, after many ages and one “restitution of all
things,” Acts iii. 21. it will be
the same for Gabriel as for the devil, for Paul as for Caiaphas, for
virgins as for prostitutes. When once you have rejected these
misstatements and have parted them with your censor’s wand from
the faith of the Church, I may read what is left with safety, and
having first taken the antidote need no longer dread the poison. For
instance it will do me no harm to say as I have said, “Whereas in
his other books Origen has surpassed all other writers, in commenting
on the Song of Songs he has surpassed himself”; nor will I fear
to face the words with which formerly in my younger days I spoke of him
as a doctor of the churches. See
Jerome’s preface to his version of Origen’s Homilies on
Ezekiel: and his preface to his own Treatise on Hebrew Names. See also
Letter XXXIII. Will it be
pretended, that I was bound to accuse a man whose works I was
translating by special request? that I was bound to say in my preface,
“This writer whose books I translate is a heretic: beware of him,
reader, read him not, flee from the viper: or, if you are bent on
reading him, know that the treatises which I have translated have been
garbled by heretics and wicked men; yet you need not fear, for I have
corrected all the places which they have corrupted,” that in
other words I ought to have said: “the writer that I translate is
a heretic, but I, his translator, am a Catholic.” The fact is
that you and your party in your anxiety to be straightforward,
ingenuous, and honest, have paid too little regard to the precepts of
rhetoric and to the devices of oratory. For in admitting that his books
On First Principles are heretical and in trying to lay the blame
of this upon others, you raise difficulties for your readers; you
induce them to examine the whole life of the author and to form a
judgment on the question from the remainder of his writings. I on the
other hand have been wise enough to emend silently what I wished to
emend: thus by ignoring the crime I have averted prejudice from the
criminal. Doctors tell us that serious maladies ought not to be
subjected to treatment, but should be left to nature, lest the remedies
applied should intensify the disease. It is now almost one hundred and
fifty years since Origen died at Tyre. Origen died at
Tyre about the year 255 a.d. Yet what Latin writer has ever ventured
to translate his books On the Resurrection and On First
Principles, his Miscellanies See note on
Letter LXX. § 4. and his Commentaries or as he
himself calls them his Tomes? τόμοι. Who has
ever cared by so infamous a work to cover himself with infamy? I am not
more eloquent than Hilary or truer to the faith than Victorinus who
both have rendered his Homilies Tractatus.not in exact versions but in
independent paraphrases. Recently also Ambrose appropriated his Six
Days’ Work, Hexaëmeron:
an account of the creation is meant. but in such a
way that it expressed the views of Hippolytus and Basil rather than of
Origen. You profess to take me for your model, and blind as moles in
relation to others you scan me with the eyes of gazelles. Well, had I
been ill-disposed towards Origen, I might have translated these very
books so as to make his worst writings known to Latin readers; but this
I have never done; and, though many have asked me, I have always
refused. For it has never been my habit to crow over the mistakes of
men whose talents I admire. Origen himself, were he still alive, would
soon fall out with you his would-be patrons and would say with Jacob:
“Ye have troubled me to make me to stink among the inhabitants of
the land.” Gen. xxxiv. 30.