§24. His elaborate account of degrees and differences in ‘works’ and ‘energies’ within the
Trinity is absurd.
Now let us see what he adds, as the consequence of this. After saying that we must per-
force regard the Being as greater and less and that while136 the ones, by virtue of a pre-em-
inent magnitude and value, occupy a leading place, the others must be detruded to a lower
place, because their nature and their value is secondary, he adds this; “their difference
amounts to that existing between their works: it would in fact be impious to say that the
same energy produced the angels or the stars, and the heavens or man; but one would pos-
itively maintain about this, that in proportion as some works are older and more honourable
than others, so does one energy transcend another, because sameness of energy produces
sameness of work, and difference of work indicates difference of energy.”
I suspect that their author himself would find it difficult to tell us what he meant when
he wrote those words. Their thought is obscured by the rhetorical mud, which is so thick
that one can hardly see beyond any clue to interpret them. “Their difference amounts to
that existing between their works” is a sentence which might be suspected of coming from
some Loxias of pagan story, mystifying his hearers. But if we may make a guess at the drift
of his observations here by following out those which we have already examined, this would
be his meaning, viz., that if we know the amount of difference between one work and another,
we shall know the amount of that between the corresponding energies. But what “works”
he here speaks of, it is impossible to discover from his words. If he means the works to be
observed in the creation, I do not see how this hangs on to what goes before. For the question
was about Father, Son, and Holy Ghost: what occasion was there, then, for one thinking
rationally to inquire one after another into the nature of earth, and water, and air, and fire,
and the different animals, and to distinguish some works as older and more honourable
than others, and to speak of one energy as transcending another? But if he calls the Only-
begotten and the Holy Spirit “works,” what does he mean by the “differences” of the energies
which produce these works: and what are 137those wonderful energies of this writer which
transcend the others? He has neither explained the particular way in which he means them
to “transcend” each other; nor has he discussed the nature of these energies: but he has ad-
vanced in neither direction, neither proving so far their real subsistence, nor their being
some unsubstantial exertion of a will. Throughout it all his meaning hangs suspended
between these two conceptions, and oscillates from one to the other. He adds that “it would
be impious to say that the same energy produced the angels or the stars, and the heavens or
136 τὰς μὲν, i.e. Οὑσίος. Eunomius’ Arianism here degenerates into mere Emanationism: but even in this
system the Substances were living: it is best on the whole to translate οὐσία ‘being,’ and this, as a rule, is adhered
to throughout.
137 κᾀκείναι αἱ ἐνεργείαι αὖται.
His elaborate account of degrees and differences in 'works' and 'energies' within the Trinity is absurd.
123
His elaborate account of degrees and differences in 'works' and 'energies'…