Socrates, Sozomen, and Gelasius affirm that the Synod of
Nicæa, as well as that of Elvira (can. 33), desired to pass a law
respecting celibacy. This law was to forbid all bishops, priests
and deacons (Sozomen adds subdeacons), who were married at the time of
their ordination, to continue to live with their wives. But, say
these historians, the law was opposed openly and decidedly by
Paphnutius, bishop of a city of the Upper Thebaïs in Egypt, a man
of a high reputation, who had lost an eye during the persecution under
Maximian. He was also celebrated for his miracles, and was held
in so great respect by the Emperor, that the latter often kissed the
empty socket of the lost eye. Paphnutius declared with a loud
voice, “that too heavy a yoke ought not to be laid upon the
clergy; that marriage and married intercourse are of themselves
honourable and undefiled; that the Church ought not to be injured by an
extreme severity, for all could not live in absolute continency:
in this way (by not prohibiting married intercourse) the virtue of the
wife would be much more certainly preserved (viz. the wife of a
clergyman, because she might find injury elsewhere, if her husband
withdrew from her married intercourse). The intercourse of a man
with his lawful wife may also be a chaste intercourse. It would
therefore be sufficient, according to the ancient tradition of the
Church, if those who had taken holy orders without being married were
prohibited from marrying afterwards; but those clergymen who had been
married only once as laymen, were not to be separated from their wives
(Gelasius adds, or being only a reader or cantor).” This
discourse of Paphnutius made so much the more impression, because he
had never lived in matrimony himself, and had had no conjugal
intercourse. Paphnutius, indeed, had been brought up in a
monastery, and his great purity of manners had rendered him especially
celebrated. Therefore the Council took the serious words of the
Egyptian bishop into consideration, stopped all discussion upon the
law, and left to each cleric the responsibility of deciding the point
as he would.