Though consideration of the case moves me, yet charity
also impels me to write, since I have written once and again to my most
holy brother the lord John, but have received no letter from him.
For some one else, a secular person, addressed me under his name;
seeing that, if those were really his letters, I have not been
vigilant, having believed of him something far different from what I
have found. For I had written about the case of the most reverend
presbyter John, and about the questions of the monks of Isauria, one of
whom, being in priest’s orders,
has been beaten with clubs in your
church; and thy most holy Fraternity (as appears from the signature of
the letter) has written back to me professing ignorance of what I wrote
about. At this reply I was exceedingly astonished, revolving
within myself in silence, if he speaks the truth, what can be worse
than that such things should be done against the servants of
God, and even he who was close at hand should
not know? For what excuse can a shepherd have if the wolf devours
the sheep and the shepherd knows it not? But, if your Holiness
knew both what I referred to in my letter and what had been done,
whether against John the presbyter or against Athanasius, monk of
Isauria and presbyter, and wrote to me, I know not; what can I reply to
this, since the Truth says through His Scripture, The mouth that
lieth slayeth the soul (Wisd. i. 11)? I demand of thee, most
holy brother; has that so great abstinence of thine come to this, that
by denial thou wouldest hide from thy brother what thou knewest to have
been done? Had it not been better that flesh should go into that
mouth for food, than that falsehood should come out of it for deceiving
a neighbour; especially when the Truth says, Not that which goeth
into the mouth defileth a man; but that which cometh out of the mouth,
this defileth a man (Matth. xv. 11)? But far be it from me to
believe anything of the kind of your most holy heart. Those
letters were headed with your name, but I do not think they were
yours. I had written to the most blessed lord John; but I believe
that that familiar of yours has replied,—that youngster, who as
yet has learnt nothing about God; who knows
not the bowels of charity; who in his wicked doings is accused by all;
who daily lays snares against the deaths of divers people by means of
concealed wills; who neither fears God nor
regards men. Believe me, most holy brother, you must first
correct this man, that from the example of those who are near to you
those who are not near may be better amended. Do not give ear to
his tongue: he ought to be directed after the counsel of your
holiness; not your holiness swayed by his words. For, if you
listen to him, I know that you cannot have peace with your
brethren. For I, as my conscience bears me witness, wish to
quarrel with no man; and with all my power I avoid it. And,
though I desire exceedingly to be at peace with all mankind, it is
especially so with you, whom I exceedingly love, if only you are
yourself the person whom I knew. For, if you do not observe the
canons, and wish to tear to pieces the statutes of the Fathers, I know
not who you are. So act, then, most holy and most dear brother,
that we may mutually recognize each other, lest, if the ancient foe
should move us two to take offence, he slay many through his most
atrocious victory. As for me, to shew that I seek to do nothing
in a haughty spirit, if that youngster of whom I have before spoken did
not hold the topmost place of evil doing with thy Fraternity, I could
meanwhile have passed over in silence what is ready to my hand from the
canons, and have sent back to thee with confidence the persons who came
to me at the first, knowing that your Holiness would receive them with
charity. But even now I say; Either receive these same persons,
restoring them to their orders, and leaving them in quiet; or, if
perchance thou art unwilling to do this, observe in their case the
statutes of the Fathers and the definitions of the canons, putting
aside all altercation with me. But, if thou shouldest do neither,
we indeed are unwilling to bring on a quarrel, but still do not shun
one if it comes from your side. Moreover your Fraternity knows
well what the canons say about bishops who desire to inspire fear by
blows. For we have been made shepherds, not persecutors.
And the excellent preacher says, Argue, beseech, rebuke, with all
longsuffering and doctrine (2 Tim. iv. 2). But new and unheard of is this
preaching, which exacts faith by blows. But I need not speak at
length by letter about these things, since I have sent my most beloved
son, the deacon Sabinianus, as my representative in ecclesiastical
matters, to the threshold of our lords; and he will speak with you
about everything more particularly. Unless you are disposed to
wrangle with us, you will find him prepared for all that is just.
Him I commend to your Blessedness, that he at least may find that lord
John whom I knew in the royal city.