Arianism was a novelty. Yet it combines in an
inconsistent whole elements of almost every previous attempt to
formulate the doctrine of the Person of Christ. Its sharpest antithesis
was Modalism: yet with the modalist Arius maintained the strict
personal unity of the Godhead. With dynamic monarchianism it held the
adoptionist principle in addition; but it personified the Word and
sacrificed the entire humanity of Christ. In this latter respect it
sided with the Docetæ, most Gnostics, and Manichæans, to all
of whom it yet opposes a sharply-cut doctrine of creation and of the
transcendence of God. With Origen and the Apologists before him it made
much of the cosmic mediation of the Word in contrast to the redemptive
work of Jesus; with the Apologists, though not with Origen, it
enthroned in the highest place the God of the Philosophers: but against
both alike it drew a sharp broad line between the Creator and the
Universe, and drew it between the Father and the Son. Least of all is
Arianism in sympathy with the theology of Asia,—that of Ignatius,
Irenæus, Methodius, founded upon the Joannine tradition. The
profound Ignatian idea of Christ as the Λόγος ἀπὸ
σιγῆς
προελθών is in
impressive contrast with the shallow challenge of the Thalia,
‘Many words hath God spoken, which of these was manifested in the
flesh?’