26. (continued). Nor is answer needful to their other very simple and
foolish inquiry, which they put to silly women; or none besides that
which has been already given, namely, that it is not suitable to
measure divine generation by the nature of men. However, that as before
they may pass judgment on themselves, it is well to meet them on the
same ground, thus:—Plainly, if they inquire of parents concerning
their son, let them consider whence is the child which is begotten.
For, granting the parent had not a
son before his begetting, still, after having him, he had him, not as
external or as foreign, but as from himself, and proper to his essence
and his exact image, so that the former is beheld in the latter, and
the latter is contemplated in the former. If then they assume from
human examples that generation implies time, why not from the same
infer that it implies the Natural and the Proper Supr.
de Decr. 6. The question was, What was that sense of Son
which would apply to the Divine Nature? The Catholics said that its
essential meaning could apply, viz. consubstantiality, whereas
the point of posteriority to the Father depended on a condition,
time, which could not exist in the instance of God. ib. 10. The
Arians on the other hand said, that to suppose a true Son, was to think
of God irreverently, as implying division, change, &c. The
Catholics replied that the notion of materiality was quite as foreign
from the Divine Essence as time, and as the Divine Sonship was eternal,
so was it also clear both of imperfection or extension., instead of extracting serpent-like from the
earth only what turns to poison? Those who ask of parents, and say,
‘Had you a son before you begot him?’ should add,
‘And if you had a son, did you purchase him from without as a
house or any other possession?’ And then you would be answered,
‘He is not from without, but from myself. For things which are
from without are possessions, and pass from one to another; but my son
is from me, proper and similar to my essence, not become mine from
another, but begotten of me; wherefore I too am wholly in him, while I
remain myself what I am It is
from expressions such as this that the Greek Fathers have been accused
of tritheism. The truth is, every illustration, as being incomplete on
one or other side of it, taken by itself, tends to heresy. The title
Son by itself suggests a second God, as the title Word a mere
attribute, and the title Instrument a creature. All heresies are
partial views of the truth, and are wrong, not so much in what they
say, as in what they deny. The truth, on the other hand, is a positive
and comprehensive doctrine, and in consequence necessarily mysterious
and open to misconception. vid. de Syn. 41, note 1. When Athan,
implies that the Eternal Father is in the Son, though remaining what He
is, as a man in his child, he is intent only upon the point of the
Son’s connaturality and equality, which the Arians denied. Cf.
Orat. iii. §5; Ps.-Ath. Dial. i. (Migne xxviii. 1144
C.). S. Cyril even seems to deny that each individual man may be
considered a separate substance except as the Three Persons are such
(Dial. i. p. 409); and S. Gregory Nyssen is led to say that,
strictly speaking, the abstract man, which is predicated of
separate individuals, is still one, and this with a view of
illustrating the Divine Unity. ad Ablab. t. 2. p. 449. vid.
Petav. de Trin. iv. 9..’ For so it
is; though the parent be distinct in time, as being man, who himself
has come to be in time, yet he too would have had his child ever
coexistent with him, but that his nature was a restraint and made it
impossible. For Levi too was already in the loins of his
great-grandfather, before his own actual generation, or that of his
grandfather. When then the man comes to that age at which nature
supplies the power, immediately, with nature, unrestrained, he becomes
father of the son from himself.