SECT. II.
Some observations on the connexions, scope, and sense of this remarkable paragraph,
Rom. v. 12,
&c. With some reflections on the evidence which we here have of the doctrine of original sin.
The connexion of this remarkable paragraph with the foregoing discourse in this epistle, is not obscure and difficult, nor to be sought for at a distance. It may be plainly seen, only by a general glance on what goes before, from the beginning of the epistle: and indeed what is said immediately before in the same chapter, leads directly to it. The apostle in the preceding part of this epistle had largely treated of the
sinfulness
and
misery
of all
mankind,
Jews
as well as
Gentiles.
He had particularly spoken of the depravity and ruin of mankind in their natural state, in the foregoing part of this chapter; representing them as being
sinners, ungodly, enemies,
exposed to divine
wrath,
and
without strength.
This naturally leads him to observe,
how
this so great and deplorable an event came to pass;
how
this universal sin and ruin came into the world. And with regard to the
Jews
in
particular, though they might allow the doctrine of original sin in profession, they were strongly prejudiced against what was implied in it, or evidently followed from it, with regard to themselves. In this respect they were prejudiced against the doctrine of universal sinfulness, and exposedness to wrath by nature, looking on themselves as by nature holy, and favourites of God, because they were the children of
Abraham
; and with them the apostle had laboured most in the foregoing part
of the epistle, to convince them of their being by nature as sinful, and as much the children of wrath, as the
Gentiles
: it was therefore exceeding proper, and what the apostle’s design most naturally led him to, that they should take off their eyes from their father
Abraham,
their father in distinction from other nations, and direct them to their father
Adam,
who was the common father of mankind, equally of
Jews
and
Gentiles.
And when he had entered on
this doctrine of the derivation of sin and death, to all mankind from
Adam,
no wonder if he thought it needful to be somewhat particular in it, seeing he wrote to
Jews
and
Gentiles
; the former of which had been brought up under the prejudices of a proud opinion of themselves, as a holy people by nature, and the latter had been educated in total ignorance.
Again, the apostle had, from the beginning of the epistle, been endeavouring to evince the absolute dependence of all mankind on the free
grace
of god for salvation, and the greatness of this grace; and particularly in the former part of this chapter. The greatness of this grace he shows especially by two things. (1.) The universal corruption and misery of mankind; as in all the foregoing chapters, and in several preceding verses of this chapter, (
ver. 6-10.
) (2.) The greatness of the benefits which believers receive, and the greatness of the glory for which they hope. So especially in
ver. 1-5,
and
11th of this chapter
. And here,
ver. 12
, to the end, he still pursues the same design of magnifying the grace of God, in the favour, life, and happiness which believers in
Christ receive; speaking here of
the grace of God, the gift by grace, the abounding of grace, and the reign of grace.
And he still sets forth the freedom and riches of grace by the same two arguments,
viz.
The universal
sinfulness
and
ruin
of mankind, all having sinned, all being naturally exposed to death, judgment, and condemnation; and the exceeding greatness of the benefit received, being far greater than the misery which comes by the first Adam, and abounding
beyond it. And it is by no means consistent with the apostle’s scope, to suppose, that the benefit which we have by Christ, as the antitype of Adam, here mainly insisted on, is without any grace at all, being only a restoration to life of such as never deserved death.
Another thing observable in the apostle’s grand scope from the beginning of the epistle, is, that he endeavours to show the greatness and absoluteness of dependence on the
redemption
and
righteousness
of christ, for justification and life, that he might
magnify
and
exalt
the
Redeemer
; in which design his whole heart was swallowed up, and may be looked upon as the main design of the whole epistle. And this is what he had been upon in
the preceding part of this chapter, inferring it from the same argument, even the utter sinfulness and ruin of all men. And he is evidently still on the same thing from the 12th verse to the end; speaking of the
same
justification and righteousness, which he had dwelt on before, and not another totally diverse. No wonder, when the apostle is treating so fully and largely of our restoration, righteousness, and life by Christ, that he is led by it to consider our fall, sin, death, and ruin
by
Adam
; and to observe wherein these two opposite heads of mankind agree, and wherein they differ, in the manner of conveyance of opposite influences and communications from each.
Thus, if the place be understood, as it used to be understood by orthodox divines, the whole stands in a natural, easy, and clear connexion with the preceding part of the chapter, and all the former part of the epistle; and in a plain agreement with the express design of all that the apostle had been saying; and also in connexion with the words last before spoken, as introduced by the two immediately preceding verses, where he is speaking of our justification,
reconciliation, and salvation by Christ; which leads the apostle directly to observe, how, on the contrary, we have sin and death by
Adam.
Taking this discourse of the apostle in its true and plain sense, there is no need of great extent of learning, or depth of criticism, to find out the connexion. But if it be understood in Dr. T.‘s sense, the plain scope and connexion are wholly lost, and there was truly need of skill in criticism, and the art of discerning, beyond or at least
different from that of former divines, and a faculty of seeing what other men’s sight could not reach, in order to find out the connexion.
What has been already observed, may suffice to show the apostle’s general scope in this place. But yet there seem to be some
other
things to which he alludes in several expressions. As particularly the
Jews
had a very superstitious and extravagant notion of their law, delivered by
Moses
; as if it were the prime, grand, and indeed only rule of God’s proceeding with mankind as their judge, both in their justification and condemnation, or
from whence all, both sin and righteousness, was imputed; and had no consideration of the law of nature, written in the hearts of the
Gentiles,
and of all mankind. Herein they ascribed infinitely too much to their particular law, beyond the true design of it. They
made their boast of the law
; as if their being distinguished from all other nations by that great privilege,
the giving of the law,
sufficiently made them a holy people, and God’s children. This notion of
theirs the apostle evidently refers to,
chap. ii. 13, 17-19
. and indeed through that whole chapter. They looked on the law of Moses as intended to be the only rule and means of justification; and as such, trusted in the works of the law, especially circumcision; which appears by the third chapter. But as for the
Gentiles,
they looked on them as by nature sinners, and children of wrath; because born of un-circumcised parents, and aliens
from their law, and who themselves did not know, profess, and submit to the law of
Moses,
become proselytes, and receive circumcision. What they esteemed the sum of
their
wickedness, and condemnation, was, that they did not turn
Jews,
and act as
Jews
.
334
To this notion the apostle has a plain respect, and endeavours to convince them of its falseness, in
chap. ii. 12-16
. And he has a manifest regard again to the same thing here. (
Chap. v. 12-14.
) Which may lead us the more clearly to see the true sense of those verses; about the sense of which is the main controversy, and the meaning of which being determined, it will settle the meaning
of every other controverted expression through the whole discourse.
Dr. T. misrepresents the apostle’s argument in these verses; which, as has been demonstrated, is in his sense altogether vain and impertinent. He supposes, the thing which the apostle mainly intends to prove, is, that
death
or mortality does not come on mankind by
personal
sin; and that he would prove it by this medium, that
death reigned
when there was
no law
in being which threatened personal sin with death. It is acknowledged, that this
is
implied, even that death came into the world by
Adam’s
sin: yet this is not the
main
thing the apostle designs to prove. But his main point evidently is, that
sin
and
guilt,
and
just exposedness to death and ruin,
came into the world by
Adam’s
sin; as
righteousness, justification,
and a
title to eternal life
come by Christ. Which point he confirms by this consideration, that from the very time when
Adam
sinned, sin,
guilt, and desert of ruin, became
universal
in the world, long before the law given by
Moses
to the
Jewish
nation had any being.
The apostle’s remark, that sin entered into the world by
one man,
who was the father of the whole human race, was an observation which afforded proper instruction for the
Jews,
who looked on themselves as an holy people, because they had the law of
Moses,
and were the children of
Abraham,
an holy father; while they looked on other nations as by nature unholy and sinners, because they were not Abraham’s children. He leads them up to a
higher ancestor than this patriarch, even to Adam, who being equally the father of
Jews
and
Gentiles,
both alike come from a sinful father; from whom guilt and pollution were derived alike to all mankind. And this the apostle proves by an argument, which of all that could possibly be invented, tended the most briefly and directly to convince the
Jews
; even by this reflection, that death had come equally on all mankind from
Adam’s
time, and that the
posterity of
Abraham
were equally subject to it with the rest of the world. This was apparent in
fact,
a thing they all knew. And the Jews had always been taught, that
death
(which began in the destruction of the body, and of this present life) was the proper punishment of
sin.
This they were taught in
Moses’s
history of
Adam,
and God’s first threatening of punishment for sin, and by the constant doctrine of the law and the prophets; as already
observed.
And the apostle’s observation—that
sin
was in the world
long before the
law
was given, and was as
universal
in the world from the times of Adam, as it had been among the heathen since the law of Moses—showed plainly, that the
Jews
were quite mistaken in their notion of their particular law; and that the
law
which is the original and universal rule of righteousness and judgment for all mankind, was another law, of far more
ancient date, even the law of nature. This began as early as the human nature began, and was established with the first father of mankind, and in him with the whole race. The positive precept of abstaining from the forbidden fruit, was given for the trial of his compliance with this law of nature; of which the main rule is supreme regard to God and his will. And the apostle proves that it must be thus, because if the law of
Moses
had been the highest rule of judgment, and if there had
not been a superior, prior, divine rule established, mankind in general would not have been judged and condemned as sinners,
before
that was given, (for “sin is not imputed, when there is no law,”) as it is apparent in fact they were, because
death reigned
before that time, even from the time of
Adam.
It may be observed, that the apostle, both in this epistle, and in that to the
Galatians,
endeavours to convince the
Jews
of these two things, in opposition to the notions and prejudices they had entertained concerning
their law.
(1.) That it never was intended to be the
covenant,
or method by which they should actually be
justified.
(2.) That it was not the
highest
and
universal
rule or law, by which mankind in
general, and particularly the heathen world, were
condemned.
And he proves both by similar arguments.—He proves, that the law of
Moses
was not the
covenant,
by which any of mankind were to
obtain justification,
because that covenant was of older date, being expressly established in the time of
Abraham,
and Abraham himself was
justified
by it. This argument the apostle particularly handles in the
third chapter of
Galatians,
particularly in
ver. 17-19.
and especially in
Rom. iv. 13-15.
He proves also, that the law of
Moses
was not the
prime
rule of judgment, by which mankind in general, and particularly the heathen world, were
condemned.
And this he proves also the same way,
viz.
by showing this to be of
older date
than that law, and that it was established with
Adam.
Now, these things tended to lead the
Jews
to right notions of their law, not as the intended method of
justification,
nor as the original and universal rule of
condemnation,
but something
superadded
to both; superadded to the
latter,
to illustrate and confirm it, that the
offence might abound
; and superadded to
the former,
to be as a schoolmaster, to prepare men for its benefits., and to magnify divine
grace
in it, that this
might
much more abound.
The chief occasion of obscurity and difficulty, attending the scope and connexion of the various clauses of this discourse, particularly in
the 13th and 14th verses,
is that there are
two
things (although closely connected) which the apostle has in view
at once.
He would illustrate the grand point he had been upon from the beginning, even
justification through Christ’s righteousness alone,
by showing
how we are originally in a sinful miserable state, how we derive this sin and misery from
Adam,
and how we are delivered and justified by Christ as a second
Adam.
At the same time he would confute those foolish and corrupt notions of the
Jews,
about their
nation,
and their
law,
which were very inconsistent with these doctrines. And he here endeavours to establish, at once, these two things in opposition to those
Jewish
notions.
(1.) That it is our natural relation to
Adam,
and not to
Abraham,
which determines our native moral state; and that, therefore, being natural children
of Abraham,
will not make us by nature holy in the sight of God, since we are the natural seed of sinful
Adam.
Nor does the
Gentiles
being not descended from
Abraham,
denominate them
sinners,
any more than the
Jews,
seeing both alike are descended from
Adam.
(2.) That the law of
Moses
is not the prime and general law and rule of judgment for mankind, to
condemn
them, and denominate them
sinners
; but that the state they are in with regard to a higher, more ancient, and universal law, determines them in general to be
sinners
in the sight of God, and liable to be
condemned
as such. Which observation is, in many respects, to the apostle’s purpose; particularly in this respect, that
if the
Jews
were convinced, that the law, which was the prime rule of
condemnation,
was given to
all,
was common to all mankind, and that all fell under condemnation through the violation of that law by the common father of all, both
Jews
and
Gentiles,
then they would be led more easily and naturally to believe, that the method
of justification,
which God had established, also extended equally to
all
mankind: and that the
Messiah,
by whom
we have this justification, is appointed, as
Adam
was, for a common head to all, both
Jews and Gentiles.—
The apostle aiming to confute the
Jewish
notion, is the principal occasion of those words in
the 13th verse
, “for until the law, sin was in the world; but sin is not imputed, when there is no law.”
As to the import of that expression, “even over them that had not sinned after the similitude of Adam’s transgression,” not only is the thing signified, in Dr. T.‘s sense of it,
not true
; or if it had been true, would have been impertinent, as has been shown: but his interpretation is, otherwise, very much
strained
and unnatural. According to him, “by sinning after the similitude of Adam’s transgression,” is not meant any similitude of the act of
sinning, nor of the command sinned against, nor properly any circumstance of the
sin
; but only the similitude of a circumstance of the
command, viz. the threatening
with which it is attended. A far-fetched thing, truly, to be called a
similitude of sinning
! Besides, this expression in such a meaning, is only a needless, impertinent, and awkward
repetition
of the same thing, which it is supposed the apostle had observed in the foregoing verse, even after
he had proceeded another step in the series of his discourse. As thus, in the foregoing verse the apostle had plainly laid down his argument, (as our author understands it,) by which he would prove, that
death
did not come by
personal sin, viz.
because death reigned before any
law, threatening
death for personal sin, was in being: so that the sin then committed was against
no law,
threatening death for personal sin. Having laid this down, the apostle leaves this part
of his argument, and proceeds another step,
nevertheless death reigned from Adam to Moses
: and then returns, in a strange unnatural manner, and
repeats
that argument or assertion again, but only more obscurely than before, in these words,
even over them that had not sinned after the similitude of Adams transgression
;
i. e.
over them that had not sinned against a law threatening death for personal
sin. Which is just the same thing as if the apostle
had said, “they that sinned
before the law,
did not sin against a law threatening death for personal sin; for there was
no such law
for any to sin against at that time:
nevertheless
death reigned at that time,
even over such as did not sin
against a law threatening death for personal sin.” Which latter clause
adds
nothing to the premises, and tends nothing to illustrate what was said before, but rather to obscure and darken it. The particle (
NOT
ENGLISH
)
even,
when prefixed in this manner, is used to signify something additional, some advance in the sense or argument; implying, that the words following express something more, or express the same thing more fully, plainly, or forcibly. But to unite two clauses by such a particle, in such a manner, when there is nothing besides a flat repetition, with no superadded sense or force, but rather a greater uncertainty and obscurity, would be very unusual, and indeed very absurd.
I can see no reason why we should be dissatisfied with that explanation of this clause, which has more commonly been given,
viz.
That by
them who have not sinned after the similitude of Adam’s transgression,
are meant
infants
; who, though they have indeed sinned in Adam, yet never sinned as
Adam
did, by actually transgressing in their own persons; unless it be, that this interpretation is too
old,
and too
common.
It
was well understood by those to whom the apostle wrote, that vast numbers had
died
in infancy, within that period of which he speaks, particularly in the time of the deluge. And it would be strange, that the apostle should not have the case of such infants in his mind; even supposing his scope were what our author supposes, and he had only intended to prove that death did not come on mankind for their
personal
sin. How directly would it have served the purpose of proving this, to
have mentioned so great a part of mankind who are subject to death, and who, all know, never committed any sin
in
their own persons
! How much more plain and easy the proof of the point by that, than to go round about, as Dr. T. supposes, and bring in a thing so dark and uncertain as this, that God never would bring death on all mankind for
personal
sin (though they had personal sin) without an express revealed
constitution
; and then to observe, that there was
no
revealed constitution of this nature from
Adam
to
Moses—
which also seems to be an assertion without any plain evidence—and then to infer, that it must needs be so, that it could come only on
occasion of Adam’s sin,
though not
for
his sin, or as any punishment of it; which inference also is very dark and unintelligible.
If the apostle in this place meant those who never sinned by their personal act, it is not strange that he should express this by their
not sinning after the similitude of Adam’s transgression.
We read of two ways of men being like
Adam,
or in which a similitude to him is ascribed to men: one is, being begotten or born in his
image
or
likeness
,
Gen. v. 3.
Another is, transgressing God’s covenant or law,
like
him
,
Hos. vi. 7.
They, like Adam,
(so, in the
Heb.
and
Vulg. Lat.) have transgressed the covenant.
Infants have the former similitude, but not the latter. And it was very natural, when the apostle would infer that infants become sinners by that one act and offence of Adam, to observe, that they had not renewed the act of sin themselves, by any second instance of a like sort. And such might be the state of language among
Jews
and Christians at
that day, that the apostle might have no phrase more aptly to express this meaning. The manner in which the epithets,
personal
and
actual,
are used and applied now in this case, is probably of later date, and more modern use.
And the apostle having the case of
infants
in view, in this expression, makes it more to his purpose to mention death reigning before the law of Moses was given. For the Jews looked on all nations besides themselves, as
sinners,
by virtue of
their law
; being made so especially by the
law of circumcision,
given first to
Abraham,
and completed by
Moses,
making the want of circumcision a legal
pollution,
utterly
disqualifying for the privileges of the sanctuary. This law, the
Jews
supposed, made the very infants of the
Gentiles
to be sinners, polluted and hateful to God; they being uncircumcised, and born of uncircumcised parents. But the apostle proves, against these notions of the Jews, that the nations of the world do not become sinners by nature, and sinners from infancy, by virtue of
their law,
in this manner, but by
Adam’s
sin: inasmuch as infants were treated as
sinners long
before
the law of circumcision was given, as well as before they had committed actual sin.
What has been said, may, as I humbly conceive, lead us to that which is the
true
scope and sense of the apostle in these three verses; which I will endeavour more briefly to represent in the following
paraphrase.
“The things which I have largely insisted on, viz. the evil that is in the world, the general wickedness, guilt, and ruin of mankind, and the opposite good, even justification and life, as only by Christ, lead me to observe the
likeness
of the manner in which they are each of them
introduced.
For it was by
one man
that the general corruption and guilt which I have spoken of, came into the world, and condemnation and death by sin: and this
dreadful punishment and ruin came on all mankind by the great
law of works,
originally established with mankind in their first father, and by his
one offence,
or breach of that law;
all
thereby becoming
sinners
in God’s sight, and exposed to final destruction.
Rom. v. 12.
Wherefore, as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin; and so death passed upon all men, for that all have sinned
“It is manifest that it was in this way the world became sinful and guilty; and not in that way which the
Jews
suppose, viz. That their law, given by
Moses,
is the grand universal rule of righteousness and judgment for mankind, and that it is by being
Gentiles,
uncircumcised, and aliens from that law, that the nations of the world are
constituted sinners,
and unclean. For
before
the law of
Moses
was given, mankind were all
looked upon by the great Judge as sinners, by corruption and guilt derived from
Adam’s
violation of the original law of works; which shows, that the original universal rule of righteousness is not the law of
Moses
; for if so, there would have been no sin imputed
before
that was given; because sin is not imputed, when there is no law.
Rom. v. 13.
For until the law sin was in the world; but sin is not imputed, when there is no law.
“But that at that time sin was
imputed,
and men were by their judge reckoned as
sinners,
through guilt and corruption derived from
Adam,
and condemned for sin
to death,
the proper punishment of sin, we have a plain proof; in that it appears in fact, all mankind, during that whole time which preceded the law of
Moses,
were subjected to that temporal death, which is the visible introduction and image of that utter destruction which
sin deserves, not excepting even
infants,
who could be sinners no other way than by virtue of
Adam’s
transgression, having never in their own persons actually sinned as
Adam
did; nor could at that time be made polluted by the law of Moses, as being uncircumcised, or born of uncircumcised parents.”
Rom. v. 14.
Nevertheless death reigned from Adam to Moses, even over them that had not sinned after the similitude of Adam’s transgression.
Now, by way of reflection on the whole, I would observe, that though there are two or three expressions in this paragraph,
Rom. v. 12,
&c. the design of which is attended with some difficulty and obscurity, as particularly in the
13th and 14th verses,
yet the scope and sense of the discourse in general is not obscure, but on the contrary very clear and manifest; and so is the particular doctrine
mainly taught in it. The apostle sets himself with great care to make it plain, and precisely to fix and settle the point he is upon. And the discourse is so framed, that one part of it greatly clears and fixes the meaning of other
parts; and the whole is determined by the clear connexion it stands in with other parts of the epistle, and by the manifest drift of all the preceding part of it.
The doctrine of
original
sin is not only here taught, but most plainly, explicitly, and abundantly taught. This doctrine is asserted, expressly or implicitly, in almost every verse, and in some of the verses several times. It is fully implied in that first expression in the
12th ver.
“By one man sin entered into the world.” The passage implies, that sin became
universal
in the world; as the apostle had before
largely shown it was; and not merely (which would be a trifling observation) that one man, who was made first, sinned first, before other men sinned; or, that it did not so happen that many men began to sin just together at the same moment. The latter part of the verse, “and death by sin, and so death passed upon all men, for that (or, if you will,
unto which)
all have sinned,”
335
shows, that in the eye of the Judge of the world, in
Adam’s
first sin,
all
sinned; not only
in some sort,
but all sinned
so
as to be exposed to that
death,
and final destruction, which is the proper
wages of sin.
The same doctrine is taught again twice over in
the 14th verse
. It is there observed, as a proof of this doctrine, that “death reigned over them which had not sinned after the similitude
of Adam’s transgression,”
i. e.
by their personal act; and therefore could be exposed to death, only by deriving guilt and pollution from
Adam,
in consequence of his sin. And it is taught again in those words,
who is the figure of him that was to come.
The resemblance lies very much in this circumstance, viz. our deriving sin, guilt, and punishment by Adam’s sin, as we do righteousness, justification, and the reward of life, by Christ’s obedience; for so the apostle
explains himself. The same doctrine is expressly taught again, ver. 15.
Rom. v. 15.
“Through the offence of one, many be dead.” And again twice in the
16th verse,
“it was by one that sinned:”
i. e.
It was by Adam, that guilt and punishment (before spoken of) came on mankind: and in these words, “judgment was by one to condemnation.”
336
It is again plainly and fully laid down in the
17th verse,
“By one man’s offence, death reigned by one.” So again in the 18th verse,
Rom. v. 18.
“By the offence of one, judgment came upon all men to condemnation.” Again very plainly in the 19th verse,
Rom. v. 19.
“By one man’s disobedience, many were made sinners.”
Here is every thing to determine and fix the
meaning
of all the important
terms
used; as, the
abundant use
of them in all parts of the New Testament; and especially in this apostle’s writings, which make up a very great part of the New Testament; and his repeated use of them in this epistle in particular; and in the former part of this very chapter; and also the
light that
one sentence in this paragraph casts on another, which fully
settles their meaning: as, with respect to the words
justification, righteousness,
and
condemnation
; and above all, in regard of the word
sin
, which is the most important of all, with relation to the doctrine and controversy we are upon. Besides the constant use of this term every where else through the New Testament, through the epistles of this apostle, this epistle in particular, and even the former part of this chapter, it is often repeated in this very
paragraph, and evidently used in the very sense that is denied to belong to it in the end of
ver. 12.
and
ver. 19.
though owned every where else: and its meaning is fully determined by the apostle varying the term; using together with it, to signify the same thing, such a variety of other synonymous words, such as
offence, transgression, disobedience.
And further, to put the matter out of all
controversy, it is particularly, expressly, and repeatedly distinguished from that which our opposers would
explain
it by,
viz. condemnation
and
death.
And what is meant by
sin entering into the world,
in
ver. 12.
is determined by a like phrase of
sin being in the world,
in the next verse.—And that by the
offence of one,
so often spoken of here, as bringing death and condemnation on all, the apostle means
the
sin of one,
derived in its guilt and pollution to mankind in general, (over and above all that has been already observed,) is determined by those words in the conclusion of this discourse,
ver. 20.
“Moreover, the law entered, that the offence might abound: but where sin abounded, grace did much more abound.” These words plainly show, that the offence spoken of so often, the offence of
one
man, became the sin of
all.
For when
he says, “The law entered, that the offence might abound,” his meaning cannot be, that the offence of Adam, merely as
his
personally, should
abound
; but, as it exists in its
derived
guilt, corrupt influence, and evil fruits, in the sin of mankind in general, even as a tree in its root and branches.
337
What further confirms the certainty of the
proof of original sin,
which this place affords, is this, that the utmost art
cannot
pervert it to
another
sense. What a variety of the most artful methods have been used by the
enemies
of this doctrine, to
wrest
and
darken
this paragraph of Holy Writ, which stands so much in their way, as it were to
force
the Bible to speak a language agreeable to their mind! How have
expressions been strained, words and phrases racked! What strange figures of speech have been invented, and with violent hands thrust into the apostle’s mouth; and then with a bold countenance and magisterial airs obtruded on the world, as from him!—But blessed be God, we have his words as he delivered them, and the rest of the same epistle, and his other writings to compare with them; by which his meaning stands in too strong and glaring a light to be hid by any of the artificial mists which
they labour to throw upon it.
It is really no less than
abusing
the Scripture and its readers, to represent this paragraph as the most
obscure
of all the places of Scripture, that speak of the consequences of
Adam’s
sin; and to treat it as if there was need first to consider other places as more
plain.
Whereas, it is most manifestly a place in which these things are declared, the most plainly, particularly, precisely, and of set purpose, by that great apostle, who has
most fully explained to us those doctrines in general, which relate to the redemption by Christ, and the sin and misery we are redeemed from. And it must be now left to the reader’s judgment, whether the christian church has not proceeded reasonably, in looking on this as a place of Scripture most clearly and fully treating of these things, and in using its determinate sense as a help to settle the meaning of many other passages of Sacred Writ.
As this place in general is very full and plain, so the doctrine of the corruption of nature, as derived from Adam, and also the imputation of his first sin, are
both
clearly taught in it. The
imputation
of
Adam’s
one transgression, is indeed most directly and frequently asserted. We are here assured, that
by one man’s sin, death passed on all
; all being adjudged to this punishment, as having
sinned
(so it is implied) in that
one man’s sin. And it is repeated, over and over, that
all are condemned, many are dead, many made sinners,
&c. by
one man’s offence, by the disobedience of one,
and
by one offence.
And the doctrine of original
depravity
is also here taught, when the apostle says, “By one man sin entered into the world;” having a plain respect (as hath been shown) to that universal corruption and wickedness, as well as guilt, of which he had before largely treated.
334
Here are worthy to be observed the things which Dr. T. himself says to the same purpose, Key. § 302, 303. and Pref. to Par. on Ep. to Rom. p. 144, 43.
335
Rom. v. 12.
336
Rom. v. 16.
337
The offence, according to Dr. T.‘s explanation, docs not abound by the law at all really and truly, in any sense; neither the sin, nor the punishment. For he says, “The meaning is not, that men should be made more wicked; but, that men should be liable to death for every transgression.” But after all, they are liable to no more deaths, nor to any worse deaths, if they are not more sinful: for they were to have punishments according to their desert, before.
Such as died, and went into another world, before the law of Moses was given, were punished according to their deserts; and the law, when it came, threatened no more.