and confessions, of a practical and experimental nature,) as having been found by plentiful
experience a nurse of formality and irreligion. At the same time declaring his judgment, with
a particular eye to the churches of New England, that the power of godliness will be lost, if
only doctrinal knowledge and outward behaviour come to be accounted sufficient for a title
to all church-privileges; and the use of practical confessions and examinations of men’s
spiritual estate be laid aside. For (says he) that which people see to be publicly required and
held in reputation, that will they look after, and usually no more. In another place he observes,
this will not only lose the power of godliness, but in a little time bring in profaneness and
ruin the churches, these two ways. (1.) Election of ministers will soon be carried by a formal
looser sort. (2.) The exercise of discipline will by this means be impossible.—And discipline
failing, profaneness riseth like a flood. Agreeably he says elsewhere; Certain it is, that we
stand for the purity of the churches, when we stand for such qualifications as we do, in those
whom we would admit to full communion; and do withstand those notions and reasonings
that would infer a laxness therein, which hath apparent peril in it. In sum, (says he,) we make
account that we shall be near about the middle-way of church reformation, if we keep baptism
within the compass of the non-excommunicable, and the Lord’s supper within the compass
of those that have (unto charity) somewhat of the power of godliness, or grace in exercise.
For Mr. Mitchel, as he thought faith in the special and lively exercise thereof necessary to a
safe and comfortable participation of the Lord’s supper, so he judged an appearance of this
unto rational charity, judging by positive sensible signs and evidences, justly required in order
to admission into full communion. Whereas, he thought baptism annexed to initial faith, or
faith in the being of it; the charitable judgment whereof (says he) runs upon a great latitude;
and he conceived the same strictness, as to outward signs, not necessary unto a charitable
probable judgment, or hope of the being of faith, which entitles to baptism, as of that growth
and special exercise of faith, which is requisite to the Lord’s supper. These are the main dis-
tinctions, on which he grounded his opinion of a different latitude of the two sacraments.
For I must observe, as strenuously as he pleads for a various extent, as to the subjects of
them, he never supposes any adult regularly admittable to either sacrament, but such as in
ecclesiastical reputation sustain the character of believers; such as in the account of a rational
charity (judging by probable signs) have the being of regeneration; or as he variously expresses
it, have true faith, in the judgment of charity; and do in some measure perform the duties
of faith and obedience, as to church-visibility and charitable hope; and therefore are such as
the church ought to receive and hold as heirs of the grace of life, according to the rules of
christian charity. Though it seems Mr. Shepard before him speaks of his church charity and
experimental charity; so Mr. Mitchel had his positive charity and his negative, and conducted
his judgment and administrations accordingly, in admitting persons to the one sacrament
or the other. I should not have been so prolix and particular here, but that I thought it might
1887
Appendix. Mr. Foxcroft's letter.